Vanos Rebuild Start Hesitation

[jamesfoley]

First start after the car sat for a week while I was on holiday, hesitatesas the engine was trying to catch while cranking and then runs fine.

[jamesfoley]

Here is a good one, roughly 3 hours after the video in my above post. Hesitation at start and ran rough until RPM settled just under 1k:

[jamesfoley]

Got TestO working graphing both bank 1 intake and exhaust camshaft actual positions and DME expected positions.

I have no idea what the exhaust cam is doing when it fires up, but thats where the hesitation I feel is. This is a smaller hesitation than usual, but logging every engine start with my laptop is a ball ache. Video is of the same start, doesn't really come across well but it can be felt and heard in the car, this one being one of its better starts so hesitation is short.

Car hasn't been used for around 2 days before this start, so cold engine.

I'm assuming TestO reporting values for bank 2 is normal? With only 1 intake and 1 exhaust sensor, not sure where the exhaust bank 2 actual value is coming from in that left hand side table.

[sapote]

I see what you mean but I think that’s just where the front of the VANOS body is not the same as the front of the piston. Back side of the piston is generally the side with the larger surface area that pushes the piston outward, regardless of orientation.

On the car, the best way for everyone to agree is to use the car body when referring to left right front and rear sides.

Part orientation should be referenced the same way.

[jamesfoley]

2. If the engineers wanted to have the cams at max advanced during cranking as I think, then during engine shut off, the DME detects the key turned off, then it energizes both intake solenoids to pressurize the larger end of the pistons to advance the cam as the rpm slowing down. Why not? Then during cranking, the DME also energize the same two intake solenoids to keep the pistons at the same advanced position.

Yes, at idle the cams should be in their default positions so when shut off they are at the ideal positions for next start. It pulses all solenoids fast using the high oil pressure until it achieves the cam angle it needs. I don’t think that the oil pressure exists during cranking to do this.

1. See how concficting the 2 highlighted statements? And you said the larger end of the piston is the front side covered by the cap

I see what you mean but I think that’s just where the front of the VANOS body is not the same as the front of the piston. Back side of the piston is generally the side with the larger surface area that pushes the piston outward, regardless of orientation.

[sapote]

1. The front side is the smaller chamber which has a constant pressure applied. The back side which is the larger chamber is where pressure is fed or bled by the solenoids. The larger surface area on the back side allows the same amount of pressure to overcome the pressure in the smaller chamber, moving the piston forward toward the engine. When pressure is bled from the large chamber the pressure in the small chamber pushes the piston backward away from the engine. Large chamber would be the side with the cap on the front of the VANOS body.

2. I don’t really know how it works without VANOS influence as it appears the small chamber always has high pressure applied regardless, and oil in the large chamber should be sealed by the solenoids, so disabling VANOS or unplugging the solenoid pack should mean the pistons are just locked at whatever their last position was.

3. Also not sure what happens to piston position when pressure eventually bleeds off on the small chamber side as the engine is shut down.

1. See how concficting the 2 highlighted statements? And you said the larger end of the piston is the front side covered by the cap
2. You're right that without power applied to the solenoids, this keeps the pistons at the last positions.
3. it should stay the same place as the sealed oil in the front cannot push it to move.

[sapote]

1. I don’t really know how it works without VANOS influence as it appears the small chamber always has high pressure applied regardless, and oil in the large chamber should be sealed by the solenoids, so disabling VANOS or unplugging the solenoid pack should mean the pistons are just locked at whatever their last position was.

2. Also not sure what happens to piston position when pressure eventually bleeds off on the small chamber side as the engine is shut down.

1. What does it mean "without vanos influence"? No oil pressure, or solenoids are not energized?
For no oil pressure, then the rotation of the sprockets apply a force on the helical splined shafts, cause them to move forward to their max retarded.
For no power applied to any solenoids then they all closed, so the constant oil pressure on the smaller side will push both pistons forward to their max retarded.
So either cases would cause cams to be retarded at 130 for IN and 83 for EX, and this is another proof that the Manual is wrong saying ADVANCED 83*
Edited: I was wrong on this. If no power applied to solenoids then they are closed to seal the front chambers, and so the pistons should not move instead of moving to the max retarded as I wrote above.

2. If the engineers wanted to have the cams at max advanced during cranking as I think, then during engine shut off, the DME detects the key turned off, then it energizes both intake solenoids to pressurize the larger end of the pistons to advance the cam as the rpm slowing down. Why not? Then during cranking, the DME also energize the same two intake solenoids to keep the pistons at the same advanced position.

[sapote]

The front side is the smaller chamber .

The smaller end with the hex is threaded to the splined shaft, and this is the rear side. No?

[jamesfoley]

They call the larger side of the piston as the back side, but it should be the front side of the piston according to the convention.

The front side is the smaller chamber which has a constant pressure applied. The back side which is the larger chamber is where pressure is fed or bled by the solenoids. The larger surface area on the back side allows the same amount of pressure to overcome the pressure in the smaller chamber, moving the piston forward toward the engine. When pressure is bled from the large chamber the pressure in the small chamber pushes the piston backward away from the engine. Large chamber would be the side with the cap on the front of the VANOS body.

At least that’s how the diagrams read for both S50 and S54 and how I understood it.

I don’t really know how it works without VANOS influence as it appears the small chamber always has high pressure applied regardless, and oil in the large chamber should be sealed by the solenoids, so disabling VANOS or unplugging the solenoid pack should mean the pistons are just locked at whatever their last position was.

Also not sure what happens to piston position when pressure eventually bleeds off on the small chamber side as the engine is shut down.

[sapote]

Pulled from the reference manual it says:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The “default” mechanical stop position without VANOS influence is:
Intake Camshaft = Retarded (130º spread angle)
Exhaust Camshaft = Advance (83º spread angle)

The volume of pressurized oil is stored in the accumulator supplying both adjustment pistons. Both pistons are held in the default position by the high pressure oil.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



1. S54B32 intake cam spread is 70º to 130º, so 130º would be fully retarded, and exhaust cam spread is 83º to 128º, so 83º would be fully advanced.


2. So I'm assuming this is the default position it goes back to, and the accumulator holds the pistons there. But I'm not sure the accumulator was designed to hold pressure indefinitely, videos of pressure tests show it does slowly bleed off. S62 actually has a shut off valve on the accumulator to hold pressure for the next start, but looks like that might just be to remove rattles.

Just interested to know if the VANOS is supposed to assume the default position when the engine is switched off, or if it is supposed to quickly move to that position when switched on using store accumulator pressure.

The Reference Training Manual is wrong because:
For intake, 130* is max retarded so the manual is correct on this, but
For ex, 83* should also be max retarded, not advanced as the manual says. EX valves are opened before TDC compression, and so 128* is more advanced than 83* (the same for ignition before TDC compression, that 30* is more advanced than 5*).
So the manual should say EX camshaft = Retarded (83* spread angle) instead.

So both cams should be at their max retarded by the default stop without any vanos oil pressure applied on the pistons.

Here is what happens - I think - during engine first starts up: Both sides of the piston have the same oil pressure, but the front side area is larger and so both pistons are pushed rearward to their max advanced position.

"VANOS adjustment is carried out by the ECM pulsing the inlet and outlet solenoids to allow pressurized oil to the back side of the adjustment pistons. The surface area on this side of the piston is larger so that the oil pressure is greater and the adjustment piston will move causing the valve timing to change."
They call the larger side of the piston as the back side, but it should be the front side of the piston according to the convention.

[jamesfoley]

.
It takes a long time before your camshafts start to show values which you present in your graphs, you can actually see the desired value moving once actual position starts to show a non substitute value. For me this is a sign your sensors are not reporting a correct value. Maybe it is short enough to prevent an error code to be saved. I would still try to swap/use OEM replacement exhaust and intake camshaft sensors and run a VANOS test in Tool32 like in attachment. For starting purposes I would expect the exhaust sensor to be more demanding as this camshaft trigger wheel has a missing slot to detect position and is necessary for the ECU to know which cylinder to fire and inject. No position = no injection/ignition = no / long crank.

Assuming you’re referencing the TestO graphs from way back, I think these are from before my valve replacement and head work, so might be worth double checking this is still happening now.

I think I only logged intake at the time because when I tried exhaust it’s just crash. Perhaps it’s worth me trying to get both inlet and exhaust actual readings on a hesitation.

Sort of assumed that if it was the cam sensors then the hesitation would be a little more frequent, or I’d have actual running issues.

What do you mean by it taking a long time though? In the graph the point that the expected value jumps and the wobble on the actual value starts is when the engine starts cranking.

[Tomba]

S54 is timed as
intake retard
exhaust retard.

In idle engine runs as
intake retard
exhaust advanced
these settings cause less valve overlap which reduce rest gases and improve idle performance.


Once you timed the engine and run it idle and check timing again after engine shutdown you will notice the exhaust is out of timing and advanced (moved towards rotation direction). You will need to activate VANOS solenoids and move camshaft with a wrench to move it in default position. For sure it is switched off in advanced position.
I personally use the timing tool for reference only. After timing I check the actual values by cranking the engine and activating the solenoids with a separate device and monitor actual values with a diagnostic tool before completing the engine.

It takes a long time before your camshafts start to show values which you present in your graphs, you can actually see the desired value moving once actual position starts to show a non substitute value. For me this is a sign your sensors are not reporting a correct value. Maybe it is short enough to prevent an error code to be saved. I would still try to swap/use OEM replacement exhaust and intake camshaft sensors and run a VANOS test in Tool32 like in attachment. For starting purposes I would expect the exhaust sensor to be more demanding as this camshaft trigger wheel has a missing slot to detect position and is necessary for the ECU to know which cylinder to fire and inject. No position = no injection/ignition = no / long crank.

[jamesfoley]

How much was the error? I would think a tooth wrong should cause an error code.

I'm pretty sure it was out a tooth again, but honestly not sure. I remember them telling me that the VANOS shafts (ones with the splines) should pull from the cam shafts and sprockets without binding, which mine were. Again, not a mechanic, just a guy that wants his car to work.

But yea, no code then, and no code now. DME appears to think everything is working fine.

[sapote]

The fourth time I watched them remove it and confirm the timing was wrong.

How much was the error? I would think a tooth wrong should cause an error code.

[Slideways]

Leak down was done before the head was rebuilt, its the reason we did the head, but I have no idea if a leak down or compression test was done after.

Before the head was done the car would sometimes not start at all, or stall itself, along with the hesitation. After it was done it just left me with the weird hesitation.

Yeah IDK, I would think a startup hesitation would be down to fuel issue, timing issue or compression issue. Last thing (unlikely) is something is acting up with the DME. You could swap in another DME to rule that out.