Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Best option for headers + cats

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • simon_c
    replied
    Originally posted by WestBankM4 View Post
    I ordered a set of OEM Euro headers from a board member here, waiting for those to come in. In the meantime I'm collecting the rest of the exhaust system and I'm planning on going catless initially. So far, I've got the,

    1. Karbonius CSL Intake
    2. OEM Euro headers

    In terms of Section 1, I've been researching the equal length pipes that Sunbeam sell and since I've bought a few Rogue Engineering parts, I'm going to jump for their equal length rasp pipe, really curious about the sound. With that said, any suggestions on a section 2 or should I leave it OEM? For shits and giggles I'm thinking of ordering a full titanium exhaust from AliBaba, just to see how the tone works out with the rest of the system.
    Supersprint resonated X-pipe seems to be the way to go. I’m contemplating going this route.

    Ideal exhaust setup for me is OE euro headers/section1, SS resonated x-pipe, SS sport sec 2.
    Last edited by simon_c; 01-27-2025, 07:17 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • usdmej
    replied
    Kinda surprised but not really at rogue changing their minds on something like that. I remember they said they were not bringing it to market because their version didn't make any power, I originally asked them for a catted version but they were only interested in throwing on a cheaper low cpsi type

    Leave a comment:


  • 0-60motorsports
    replied
    Originally posted by WestBankM4 View Post
    Received an email back from RE representative,

    "Definitely coming! They’re on the way to us in about 2 weeks!


    Who’s saying it’s not coming out? I’d love (for you) and I to prove them wrong!


    Best Regards,
    xoxo
    Rogue Engineering
    201-783-8600"


    With that said, I'll probably go this route since the full titanium exhaust system is en route from China and should be due in a few weeks (I don't care, it's full fucking titanium). So as it stands once the Karb airbox goes in, Euro Headers, no cats (initially), RE equal length section 1 , OEM section 2 and the
    titanium box should make for an interesting sound. If the exhaust sucks, I may just stick with OEM or a SuperSprint Race like you guys are suggesting, I'm sure I'm going to prefer the CSL airbox singing.
    Thats great. Thanks for the update and looking forward to hearing how your car sounds.

    Leave a comment:


  • WestBankM4
    replied
    Received an email back from RE representative,

    "Definitely coming! They’re on the way to us in about 2 weeks!


    Who’s saying it’s not coming out? I’d love (for you) and I to prove them wrong!


    Best Regards,
    xoxo
    Rogue Engineering
    201-783-8600"


    With that said, I'll probably go this route since the full titanium exhaust system is en route from China and should be due in a few weeks (I don't care, it's full fucking titanium). So as it stands once the Karb airbox goes in, Euro Headers, no cats (initially), RE equal length section 1 , OEM section 2 and the
    titanium box should make for an interesting sound. If the exhaust sucks, I may just stick with OEM or a SuperSprint Race like you guys are suggesting, I'm sure I'm going to prefer the CSL airbox singing.

    Leave a comment:


  • simon_c
    replied
    Originally posted by WestBankM4 View Post

    I bought the ICV hoses from RE, I like their solution for that part. I haven't purchased anything else but what's not good about that company minus complaints about their shipping charges? Don't they have an actual E46 M3 Racecar and a team? Educate me, as I'm unaware.

    I wasn't even aware of 485designs as a company, the price is negligible for the pipe considering RE's is ~$900, the welds look a lot cleaner too. I'd be interested to buy a unit if Nick is willing to make another batch, I'll keep in touch with you 9kracing

    My car has the best parts in terms of build quality, I don't skimp especially with anything cheap. Learned my lesson early in life with Megan Racing parts for my SR20DET 240SX. Absolute trash, the welds always cracked over time. In terms of the exhaust for the M3, I haven't settled on one to be honest and nothing looks appealing except the Titanium Dixis and that's a dream at this point. I actually just bought some 30mm tips I plan on installing on the OEM box since it's quite a decent system for being OEM, the tips will help blend with the CSL diffusor. The weight is what's killing me, so I'm going to spend ~$900 for a full titanium rear box and see if it's a decent tone, weight savings alone is worth it assuming it doesn't sound like a tin can. Worst case scenario I sell it on Facebook and reinstall the OEM system.
    Supersprint sport is a really good option imo (it's what I have). It's heavy though. The tips look really great too

    Leave a comment:


  • WestBankM4
    replied
    Originally posted by usdmej View Post

    Last time I spoke with rogue it didn't seem like they were going to follow through with bringing the equal length sec1to market

    Highly suggest some type of catalytic converter since it reduces the metallic rasp significantly, in addition to not poisoning you and others around you as much

    And you can add hearing damage to the list of health concerns if you're gonna try the alibaba titaniun sec 3 lol

    I've sent an email so I'm waiting to hear back, I'm hoping it's not DC'd so there's options if 485designs doesn't want to make anymore. Glad I didn't purchase this thing last night as the website says it's being released in February 2025.

    Leave a comment:


  • WestBankM4
    replied
    Originally posted by 9kracing View Post
    Rogue engineering and Alibaba.... poor car.

    Once Nick finishes up my Audi exhaust I'm going to see if I can get him to make another run of his equal length section 1s.

    We are excited to branch into the E46 market with an equal length section 1 option for those looking to improve upon the raspy S54. This has been designed and fabricated in house at our location in Denver, CO. -Equal length piping to account for the different lengths of the headers. This results


    If anyone wants in LMK.
    I bought the ICV hoses from RE, I like their solution for that part. I haven't purchased anything else but what's not good about that company minus complaints about their shipping charges? Don't they have an actual E46 M3 Racecar and a team? Educate me, as I'm unaware.

    I wasn't even aware of 485designs as a company, the price is negligible for the pipe considering RE's is ~$900, the welds look a lot cleaner too. I'd be interested to buy a unit if Nick is willing to make another batch, I'll keep in touch with you 9kracing

    My car has the best parts in terms of build quality, I don't skimp especially with anything cheap. Learned my lesson early in life with Megan Racing parts for my SR20DET 240SX. Absolute trash, the welds always cracked over time. In terms of the exhaust for the M3, I haven't settled on one to be honest and nothing looks appealing except the Titanium Dixis and that's a dream at this point. I actually just bought some 30mm tips I plan on installing on the OEM box since it's quite a decent system for being OEM, the tips will help blend with the CSL diffusor. The weight is what's killing me, so I'm going to spend ~$900 for a full titanium rear box and see if it's a decent tone, weight savings alone is worth it assuming it doesn't sound like a tin can. Worst case scenario I sell it on Facebook and reinstall the OEM system.

    Leave a comment:


  • 0-60motorsports
    replied
    Originally posted by usdmej View Post

    Last time I spoke with rogue it didn't seem like they were going to follow through with bringing the equal length sec1to market

    Highly suggest some type of catalytic converter since it reduces the metallic rasp significantly, in addition to not poisoning you and others around you as much

    And you can add hearing damage to the list of health concerns if you're gonna try the alibaba titaniun sec 3 lol

    Would love a section one with cats solution on a more affordable level vs SS


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

    Leave a comment:


  • usdmej
    replied
    Originally posted by WestBankM4 View Post

    In terms of Section 1, I've been researching the equal length pipes that Sunbeam sell and since I've bought a few Rogue Engineering parts, I'm going to jump for their equal length rasp pipe, really curious about the sound. With that said, any suggestions on a section 2 or should I leave it OEM? For shits and giggles I'm thinking of ordering a full titanium exhaust from AliBaba, just to see how the tone works out with the rest of the system.
    Last time I spoke with rogue it didn't seem like they were going to follow through with bringing the equal length sec1to market

    Highly suggest some type of catalytic converter since it reduces the metallic rasp significantly, in addition to not poisoning you and others around you as much

    And you can add hearing damage to the list of health concerns if you're gonna try the alibaba titaniun sec 3 lol


    Leave a comment:


  • simon_c
    replied
    Originally posted by WestBankM4 View Post
    I ordered a set of OEM Euro headers from a board member here, waiting for those to come in. In the meantime I'm collecting the rest of the exhaust system and I'm planning on going catless initially. So far, I've got the,

    1. Karbonius CSL Intake
    2. OEM Euro headers

    In terms of Section 1, I've been researching the equal length pipes that Sunbeam sell and since I've bought a few Rogue Engineering parts, I'm going to jump for their equal length rasp pipe, really curious about the sound. With that said, any suggestions on a section 2 or should I leave it OEM? For shits and giggles I'm thinking of ordering a full titanium exhaust from AliBaba, just to see how the tone works out with the rest of the system.
    Would love to hear your alibaba TI exhaust in person (whenever it ges installed) since you're local. Bring it out to one of the cars and coffees

    Leave a comment:


  • kwan_1104
    replied
    Originally posted by 9kracing View Post
    Rogue engineering and Alibaba.... poor car.

    Once Nick finishes up my Audi exhaust I'm going to see if I can get him to make another run of his equal length section 1s.

    We are excited to branch into the E46 market with an equal length section 1 option for those looking to improve upon the raspy S54. This has been designed and fabricated in house at our location in Denver, CO. -Equal length piping to account for the different lengths of the headers. This results


    If anyone wants in LMK.
    Can he do a catted version?

    Leave a comment:


  • 9kracing
    replied
    Rogue engineering and Alibaba.... poor car.

    Once Nick finishes up my Audi exhaust I'm going to see if I can get him to make another run of his equal length section 1s.

    We are excited to branch into the E46 market with an equal length section 1 option for those looking to improve upon the raspy S54. This has been designed and fabricated in house at our location in Denver, CO. -Equal length piping to account for the different lengths of the headers. This results


    If anyone wants in LMK.

    Leave a comment:


  • WestBankM4
    replied
    I ordered a set of OEM Euro headers from a board member here, waiting for those to come in. In the meantime I'm collecting the rest of the exhaust system and I'm planning on going catless initially. So far, I've got the,

    1. Karbonius CSL Intake
    2. OEM Euro headers

    In terms of Section 1, I've been researching the equal length pipes that Sunbeam sell and since I've bought a few Rogue Engineering parts, I'm going to jump for their equal length rasp pipe, really curious about the sound. With that said, any suggestions on a section 2 or should I leave it OEM? For shits and giggles I'm thinking of ordering a full titanium exhaust from AliBaba, just to see how the tone works out with the rest of the system.

    Leave a comment:


  • Slideways
    replied
    Originally posted by jpy1980 View Post
    Question. What's the difference btw running the OEM header/cat and OEM section 1 and someone who has an aftermarket catless header and installs a catted section 1? Is it since the cat is more downstream, there is more power to be made?
    About 10 hp and 7 ft-lbs of torque

    Leave a comment:


  • jpy1980
    replied
    Question. What's the difference btw running the OEM header/cat and OEM section 1 and someone who has an aftermarket catless header and installs a catted section 1? Is it since the cat is more downstream, there is more power to be made?

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X