Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

help and suggestions needed. SMG issue journey

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • chalaka
    replied
    Originally posted by sapote View Post

    You meant bolt #16?
    I am curious of why the torque on the bolts affects the holding pressure; lower torque causes more internal leak?
    i believe this is the idea the tech support explained to me.
    those 2 small pieces holding the butterfly o-ring and the copper plate together, and copper plate has oil venting directions .. so i think if didn't torque to spec (tight enough), it might cause pressure lost ..as those little gear keep driven by motor to build pressure, and somehow keep losing pressure?

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by chalaka View Post

    Hi,
    Yes,
    also info on this page which i found out later
    https://mlreng.com/blogs/news/e46-m3...dK6goB1ScBwDkO
    You meant bolt #16?
    I am curious of why the torque on the bolts affects the holding pressure; lower torque causes more internal leak?

    Leave a comment:


  • chalaka
    replied
    Originally posted by oceansize View Post

    As in MLR told you to torque to 7nm?
    Hi,
    Yes,
    also info on this page which i found out later

    Leave a comment:


  • oceansize
    replied
    Originally posted by chalaka View Post

    then i got suggestions from MRL about inner pump torque .. 7nm makes big difference here i guess. ..
    As in MLR told you to torque to 7nm?

    Leave a comment:


  • chalaka
    replied
    Originally posted by eacmen View Post

    You mean the pressure accumulator on the pump right? There is no accumulator on the actuator afaik.

    Did the MLR accumulator fail?

    Were you fixing any specific issues when replacing the actuator seals? Did they get fixed?
    yea, the big rod like accumulator, my original symptom was dropping out of gears ..
    car can't hold up pressure, and it's in a clear pattern .. when car gets hot, driven for like 10 minutes, dropped out of gear from 3 to N, then after a while (felt like pressure has build up enough) , car pops back to 3 ..
    then eventually time gets longer, i can't get into gears no more.

    so my 1st assumption was the pressure accumulator, i bought one, and decided to change it along with the inner seals just for the peace of mind..

    then i noticed improvement on pressure build up speed/sound .. then car still drop out of gear, but it was holding up longer..
    then i got suggestions from MRL about inner pump torque .. 7nm makes big difference here i guess. ..

    Leave a comment:


  • chalaka
    replied
    Originally posted by Mattman928 View Post
    Did you ever resolve your issues?

    Hope you don't mind if I hijack the thread, but I'm struggling with my SMG system. I replaced the SMG pump assembly last year. This winter I had to replace the clutch and the starter. When I put the system back together, the pump keeps running intermittently. With the key in the ignition, the pump runs for about 4 seconds, builds pressure, then turns off, the pressure leaks down over 10 seconds, and the pump comes on again. I monitored pressure on INPA and the pump is running wonderfully and building pressure, the system just can't seem to maintain the pressure.

    I have removed the intake and checked above pump assembly as well as under the car around the transmission and see no evidence of a leak.

    Could air be entering the system? The relay and pump seem to be working perfectly. When I removed the transmission, I disconnected the hydraulic lines from the pump housing. I did remove the Clutch slave cylinder to put a new boot on it. Other than the SMG system was not touched.

    Where could air be entering the system? Any other thoughts? Any ideas would be welcome, I am very very frustrated.
    so yours is not holding up pressure, at least the symptom is clear.

    if you have been worked on the smg related LINEs .. and the clutch slave cylinder .. perhaps leaks are these areas related..

    have you been able to go through all the bleeding steps from INPA? run it several time can take away the air in the line concern,
    if still loosing pressure, then you can continue checking on the pump itself ..

    since your pump is newly installed for 1 year only, if without touching it, wondering what could give up so quickly ..

    (1) did you loosen the smg line from the pump side or the clutch side, are those screws tight enough?
    (2) slave cylinder .. this part i am not familiar with, but fluid flows to here, are those tight?

    if they are all checked, maybe pump itself is somehow just leaks internally .. man, for the last step, you might just need to check for those ..
    or try run the accumulator pressure test as well .. at least to take out one more variable.

    Leave a comment:


  • eacmen
    replied
    Originally posted by chalaka View Post

    I just took apart my old one and replaced the o-rings bought from MLR ..

    i also replaced the pressure accumulator bought from MLR as well ..
    You mean the pressure accumulator on the pump right? There is no accumulator on the actuator afaik.

    Did the MLR accumulator fail?

    Were you fixing any specific issues when replacing the actuator seals? Did they get fixed?

    Leave a comment:


  • chalaka
    replied
    Originally posted by oceansize View Post
    Did you replace the SMG pump with a brand new BMW unit?
    I just took apart my old one and replaced the o-rings bought from MLR ..

    i also replaced the pressure accumulator bought from MLR as well ..

    Leave a comment:


  • chalaka
    replied
    Originally posted by Mattman928 View Post
    Did you ever resolve your issues?

    Hope you don't mind if I hijack the thread, but I'm struggling with my SMG system. I replaced the SMG pump assembly last year. This winter I had to replace the clutch and the starter. When I put the system back together, the pump keeps running intermittently. With the key in the ignition, the pump runs for about 4 seconds, builds pressure, then turns off, the pressure leaks down over 10 seconds, and the pump comes on again. I monitored pressure on INPA and the pump is running wonderfully and building pressure, the system just can't seem to maintain the pressure.

    I have removed the intake and checked above pump assembly as well as under the car around the transmission and see no evidence of a leak.

    Could air be entering the system? The relay and pump seem to be working perfectly. When I removed the transmission, I disconnected the hydraulic lines from the pump housing. I did remove the Clutch slave cylinder to put a new boot on it. Other than the SMG system was not touched.

    Where could air be entering the system? Any other thoughts? Any ideas would be welcome, I am very very frustrated.
    Hi~
    i have fixed my smg (i believe), have been DD with it for over 2000kms ..
    i took apart everything, and re-torque the inner pump bolts,

    additional work was on the "pressure relief valve" o-ring, i replace that small o-ring during my reinstall,
    so i pass the bleeding steps right away,

    quick notice after re-work was, motor primes up very quickly and healthy..

    hope it lasts ..

    Leave a comment:


  • oceansize
    replied
    Did you replace the SMG pump with a brand new BMW unit?

    Leave a comment:


  • Mattman928
    replied
    Did you ever resolve your issues?

    Hope you don't mind if I hijack the thread, but I'm struggling with my SMG system. I replaced the SMG pump assembly last year. This winter I had to replace the clutch and the starter. When I put the system back together, the pump keeps running intermittently. With the key in the ignition, the pump runs for about 4 seconds, builds pressure, then turns off, the pressure leaks down over 10 seconds, and the pump comes on again. I monitored pressure on INPA and the pump is running wonderfully and building pressure, the system just can't seem to maintain the pressure.

    I have removed the intake and checked above pump assembly as well as under the car around the transmission and see no evidence of a leak.

    Could air be entering the system? The relay and pump seem to be working perfectly. When I removed the transmission, I disconnected the hydraulic lines from the pump housing. I did remove the Clutch slave cylinder to put a new boot on it. Other than the SMG system was not touched.

    Where could air be entering the system? Any other thoughts? Any ideas would be welcome, I am very very frustrated.

    Leave a comment:


  • chalaka
    replied
    Originally posted by Irhase46m3 View Post

    It is definitely fixable. I do not re-oil, the pump, i try to keep it as dry as possible when assembling, once assembled and secure to pump body, before putting back the tiny filter, i drop some chf11s into the tiny hole, then rotate the pump manually from the shaft on where the electric motor the goes, this would give it some fluid so its not dry.

    hope this helps..
    your experience sharing definitely helps tons.

    I'll try to redo my work and follow all the steps suggested ~

    Leave a comment:


  • Irhase46m3
    replied
    Originally posted by chalaka View Post

    thank you so much!

    at least i am feeling more confident in the sense of understanding the whole picture of how this system is like..

    so it's definitely fixable without purchasing a new or refurbished pump from one of the vendors XD (fingers crossed)

    and you are spot on the assemble process of the inner pump!!
    i jointed them from 2 equal pieces together! and the torque thing may be an issue as well, i tried to tight them by feel, maybe what i felt is tight isn't tight enough ~
    those copper plates, and inlet, outlet holes could be confusing as well..

    From MLR's help, the following oil path was the result of recommendation they emphasized.
    Hope this can help someone's future work.
    I think i got mine right, but, i am starting to 2nd guess my work now due to the P1717 error still.

    Click image for larger version Name:	inner gear in out reference.png Views:	0 Size:	1.08 MB ID:	268889

    p.s
    do you re-oil those inner pump/gears when you reassemble them back? since it's to tight in fitting, ..
    It is definitely fixable. I do not re-oil, the pump, i try to keep it as dry as possible when assembling, once assembled and secure to pump body, before putting back the tiny filter, i drop some chf11s into the tiny hole, then rotate the pump manually from the shaft on where the electric motor the goes, this would give it some fluid so its not dry.

    hope this helps..

    Leave a comment:


  • chalaka
    replied
    Originally posted by Irhase46m3 View Post

    Yes, you are getting the picture, it is a very simple system once you understand it. High oil temp will change the viscosity which translates to pump priming more often.
    thank you so much!

    at least i am feeling more confident in the sense of understanding the whole picture of how this system is like..

    so it's definitely fixable without purchasing a new or refurbished pump from one of the vendors XD (fingers crossed)

    and you are spot on the assemble process of the inner pump!!
    i jointed them from 2 equal pieces together! and the torque thing may be an issue as well, i tried to tight them by feel, maybe what i felt is tight isn't tight enough ~
    those copper plates, and inlet, outlet holes could be confusing as well..

    From MLR's help, the following oil path was the result of recommendation they emphasized.
    Hope this can help someone's future work.
    I think i got mine right, but, i am starting to 2nd guess my work now due to the P1717 error still.

    Click image for larger version  Name:	inner gear in out reference.png Views:	0 Size:	1.08 MB ID:	268889

    p.s
    do you re-oil those inner pump/gears when you reassemble them back? since it's to tight in fitting, ..
    Last edited by chalaka; 06-20-2024, 07:30 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Irhase46m3
    replied
    Originally posted by chalaka View Post
    another good article in regards to P1717 i came across. For everyone's reference.

    A PicoScope automotive oscilloscope is used to diagnose an Electrohydraulic gearbox control fault on a 2003 BMW M3


    so, P1717 is Pump on time for too long,
    possible causes:
    - sticky faulty relay , electrical related issue causing pump to be ON for too long
    - leak somewhere, causing the pump to be ON to make up to the dropping of pressure.

    couple things to watch out:
    - how long pump primes
    - how long pump drops out of pressure
    --> using INPA to monitor such change

    for my symptom, i noticed when car's cold, issue seems to be less, GEAR yellow arrow on when car's being driven for a while ..so, maybe this
    tells that i do have internal leak somewhere (like member's suggestion, damaged inner pump oring):

    hence, when viscosity of the oil changed, causing faster drop of pressure, so pump is ON.

    but this is also weird that, sometimes PUMP primes fast, sometimes slow .. so, relay or fuse issue, maybe ..
    will see how it goes this weekend ..

    (sorry for such talking to myself type of sharing xd, just tired of dealing with SMG issue, yet, just feel so close to get it fixed )
    Yes, you are getting the picture, it is a very simple system once you understand it. High oil temp will change the viscosity which translates to pump priming more often.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X