Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

What could cause my engine to seize?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Darbshaw
    replied
    Wow you guys were on this last night. I'll try and recover as much ground as I can. I appreciate all of the feedback!

    The issue is the timing chain overhang is sealed against the head gasket. So if you remove the timing cover you could introduce a leak from the timing cover/block/head joint. I'd guess that is more of an issue with an old head gasket. If there ever was a situation where you could get away with not removing the head...it's this one.
    I can confirm that the little bit of rubber thats on the head gasket gets crushed significantly when you torque the head down to it. In this assembly I forgot to put gasket maker, and had to get a whole new head gasket. I'd imagine if I had the engine in car and wasnt mostly disassembled, I'd opt for the front cover only.

    VANOS seems to be the biggest culprit at the moment. Thats an easy enough job and can probably squeeze this in after work today. I'm not confident this is the case, I'll try and explain my reasoning as best as I can.

    1.
    OP, when you installed the VANOS unit, did you push the splined gears attached to the VANOS pistons all the way into the VANOS unit before installing the VANOS unit on to the cylinder head?
    • It looks like the post you referenced had this one step past where it needed to be. From what I can remember, I had to do a slight CCW rotation before inserting the splines. So the teeth should be correct, it doesnt hurt to check at this point
    2. The vanos is oil pressure operated right? I doubt the engine built up enough pressure in the brief starter cranking to create enough pressure in the vanos to operate. I cracked the pressure valve later on in the day and no oil came out of it.

    Click image for larger version

Name:	image.png
Views:	222
Size:	12.7 KB
ID:	314504​
    3. If there was piston to valve contact, wouldnt this be visible on a borescope? My only experience of contact is on a 7500 RPM explosion which is likely a lot more violent and this left significant signs of damage.

    4. The engine has had countless turns at this point. The timing is locked, correct or incorrect if something made contact it would have done it early I don't see how it would wait until now to sieze.


    Going back through all of this, the only thing that has changed from the last time I hand cranked until now is the flywheel, clutch, and trans. I'm leaning towards some sort of obstruction inside of the trans area, maybe a flywheel bolt backed out etc. Either way, pulling the vanos is a HELL of a lot less time consuming than dropping the trans or oil pan. Best case scenario we learn that the cams move freely and the problem is related to crank/trans area.

    Leave a comment:


  • 332
    replied
    Originally posted by bigjae46 View Post

    The issue is the timing chain overhang is sealed against the head gasket. So if you remove the timing cover you could introduce a leak from the timing cover/block/head joint. I'd guess that is more of an issue with an old head gasket. If there ever was a situation where you could get away with not removing the head...it's this one.

    You would need to remove the damper, replace the bolts and re-torque it which is a minor PIA. I still vote for removing the VANOS.
    Fun fact, my damper is one I bought from you off e46 small world

    Leave a comment:


  • 332
    replied
    Is this an SMG car or Manual?

    Leave a comment:


  • Slideways
    replied
    OP, when you installed the VANOS unit, did you push the splined gears attached to the VANOS pistons all the way into the VANOS unit before installing the VANOS unit on to the cylinder head?

    This is the only other thread I am aware of where the engine had an issue being rotated by hand - https://nam3forum.com/forums/forum/m...my-s54-rebuild

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by TexaZ3 View Post
    Vanos would be my first suggestion, especially if the engine turned by hand.
    You think bad vanos timing leading to pistons hitting valves and the lock up? It seems OP did hand turning the crank some turns, so why?

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by 332 View Post

    they lied, you can get the timing cover off without removing the head. few bolts ezpz, you can see the top holes on the cover, that bolts into the head. Remove those and the rest of the bolts, comes right off.

    ​
    It might not come out as easy as this sounds, because the head is pressing down on the timing cover.
    They didn't lie as it is hard to seal between the head and the timing cover doing your way, and not easy to pull the timing cover as there is the dowel pin on the timing cover and it's like an interference fit between timing cover and the head.
    Last edited by sapote; 08-04-2025, 09:28 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • TexaZ3
    replied
    Vanos would be my first suggestion, especially if the engine turned by hand.

    Leave a comment:


  • bigjae46
    replied
    Originally posted by 332 View Post

    they lied, you can get the timing cover off without removing the head. few bolts ezpz, you can see the top holes on the cover, that bolts into the head. Remove those and the rest of the bolts, comes right off.

    Click image for larger version Name:	image.png Views:	0 Size:	963.7 KB ID:	314334
    Click image for larger version

Name:	image.png
Views:	313
Size:	960.6 KB
ID:	314336​
    Here is a picture with the timing cover off with the head still on. ​
    The issue is the timing chain overhang is sealed against the head gasket. So if you remove the timing cover you could introduce a leak from the timing cover/block/head joint. I'd guess that is more of an issue with an old head gasket. If there ever was a situation where you could get away with not removing the head...it's this one.

    You would need to remove the damper, replace the bolts and re-torque it which is a minor PIA. I still vote for removing the VANOS.

    Leave a comment:


  • 332
    replied
    Originally posted by sapote View Post
    So it was hand crank ok, but after that the starter couldn't turn it, and hand cranking again only can move a few millimeters?

    I would remove the chain off the cam sprockets, then carefully slowly turn the crank to see if it's locked, and if not then do the same on the cams each to see if which cam is locked.


    I would remove the chain off the front of the crank before I took it off the cams. Much easier to keep the engine in time!

    Leave a comment:


  • 332
    replied
    Originally posted by Darbshaw View Post

    I'd imagine I could see if there was binding on the timing chain through my borescope but that the only thing that makes sense to me atm. According to the TIS front timing cover is shown as a head off repair. Which I'd rather not go through and drain the coolant again. As much fluid I can save the better.

    I think I'm going to attempt and peek in the trans with the scope. I'd really just love to find a smoking gun here.
    they lied, you can get the timing cover off without removing the head. few bolts ezpz, you can see the top holes on the cover, that bolts into the head. Remove those and the rest of the bolts, comes right off.

    Click image for larger version  Name:	image.png Views:	0 Size:	963.7 KB ID:	314334
    Click image for larger version

Name:	image.png
Views:	313
Size:	960.6 KB
ID:	314336​
    Here is a picture with the timing cover off with the head still on. ​
    Last edited by 332; 08-04-2025, 01:44 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by Darbshaw View Post
    Day 2: Started with a plug out crank, same as day 1 everything seemed good. Went to put the engine under compression w/ plugs in and starter click. Nothing else to it.
    So it was hand crank ok, but after that the starter couldn't turn it, and hand cranking again only can move a few millimeters?

    I would remove the chain off the cam sprockets, then carefully slowly turn the crank to see if it's locked, and if not then do the same on the cams each to see if which cam is locked.



    Leave a comment:


  • Darbshaw
    replied
    Originally posted by 332 View Post

    If you already have it opened up and have to replace the bolts, just check the bearings. Your eyes will know! Question though, did you manually turn the car over with like a pry bar before you put the pan on etc? I'm hoping you went top down, on the repairs instead of doing the rod bearings first then the HG? Nvm, I reread your OP. It's pretty easy to take the timing chain cover off, but that doesn't seem likely that the problem is there.
    I'd imagine I could see if there was binding on the timing chain through my borescope but that the only thing that makes sense to me atm. According to the TIS front timing cover is shown as a head off repair. Which I'd rather not go through and drain the coolant again. As much fluid I can save the better.

    I think I'm going to attempt and peek in the trans with the scope. I'd really just love to find a smoking gun here.

    Leave a comment:


  • 332
    replied
    Originally posted by Darbshaw View Post
    Good to know with the rod bolts, I don't think it's likely since I torqued everything to spec. I guess theres no way to know until the pan is dropped. If I have to replace the bolts, would it make sense to put fresh rod bearings? Or just send it?
    If you already have it opened up and have to replace the bolts, just check the bearings. Your eyes will know! Question though, did you manually turn the car over with like a pry bar before you put the pan on etc? I'm hoping you went top down, on the repairs instead of doing the rod bearings first then the HG? Nvm, I reread your OP. It's pretty easy to take the timing chain cover off, but that doesn't seem likely that the problem is there.
    Last edited by 332; 08-04-2025, 12:00 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Darbshaw
    replied
    Good to know with the rod bolts, I don't think it's likely since I torqued everything to spec. I guess theres no way to know until the pan is dropped. If I have to replace the bolts, would it make sense to put fresh rod bearings? Or just send it?

    Leave a comment:


  • Darbshaw
    replied
    Originally posted by bigjae46 View Post
    Total guess here, would think it would be an issue in the cylinder head. Maybe pull the vanos off and see if the cams can turn. Then see if the crank turns. I'd probably start there before tearing the motor down again.

    I have no idea if that is the best or even a good approach.
    A friend of mine reccommended to check the flywheel as well. Maybe something got caught in there or a bolt walked out. Vanos is easy enough at this point and may save me a decent headache. I'm completely lost as to what could be causing the jam, unless I have a socket extension hanging out in the oil pan. I just can't think what in the VANOS would cause the engine to sieze without there being a major colission or issue.

    Not a bad idea to start eliminating variables or connected parts

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X