I spoke with Alcon technical HQ today.
They said Castrol SRF is fine to use on any of their callipers, and indeed on any competitors that they know of. They have never heard or seen seal failure owing to SRF brake fluid.
They were professional enough not to say it outright, but I personally suspect 'seal damage' is more about niche players protecting their own brake fluid sales, especially when you need 1.5 litres of the stuff for a CSL.
Alex, I'd stick with your bargain SRF if I were you mate :-) Just make sure you flush the old stuff through properly.
Best
Jonathan
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Brake fluid
Collapse
X
-
Shimmey - SRF is DOT 4 not DOT 5, whilst it is based on a silicone ester it isn't in the class of DOT5 classified silicone fluids which is what I believe that note to refer to and indeed, it can be mixed with 5.1 fluid with no issues. No idea on issues with calliper seals though, I've used it on several cars in the past, one of which was running APs all round and no issues on that front.
I am of the school of thought that a decent fluid changed regularly is better than the ultimate fluid left in for 18 months so use the AP PFR660 DOT 4 stuff or similar.
Leave a comment:
-
instanf feedback from AP Racing
As suggested by Shimmy, I dropped an email to Mr. Pete Collen
alexk >
Dear Mr Collen,
I have a set of AP racing brakes (front and rear) for my BMW M3 CSL.
I would like to ask whether it is ok to use Castrol SRF brake fluid.
I heard from a friend that there is a problem with the seals and this brake fluid.
Can you please advise ?
Pete Collen >
Dear Sir
We have had similar reports back from the market that SRF can be aggressive to APR hydraulic seals. It should be compatible but if in doubt use APR fluid.
http://www.apracing.com/info/index.a...rake+Fluid_978
AP Racing Distributors are also listed.
Regards
Peter Collen
Leave a comment:
-
You mite as well carry on using your bollocks Duncan. while they still work! :hahaha:Originally posted by DuncanR View Post+ 1 ... but the question still remains ....do I use my brakes ?
or my bollocks ? !!!!:hahaha:
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by DuncanR View Post+ 1 ... but the question still remains ....do I use my brakes ?
or my bollocks ? !!!!:hahaha:
Bollox first, then if U absolutely, positively, necessarily have to... brakes :hahaha:
Leave a comment:
-
You're good value as always Gorilla :thumbs: Makes perfect sense to me :beer:Originally posted by The Gorilla View PostHi,
I expect if you did a Brake test between Std CSL Brakes
and a 355mm BBK Kit then then the stopping distance
between the two would be very similar.
If you then continually repeated the Brake test, over a
period the BBK would still repeat its stopping distances
more or less, whereas the Std Brakes would start to fade somewhat.
Meaning if you are a 'Light' user of the Brakes, which
usually equates to a fast driver then for light Track use,
good Pads, S/S Hoses and some ATF Blue will be
fine.
If on the other hand you ride the Brakes hard, then the
Std Brakes, even with upgrades will be showing signs
of fade in two or three laps of any Track with spirited driving.
On the question of Brake Fluid, for Track Days, ATE Blue
is as good as it gets for the money.
Reason being, that if you require the extra 60 + degrees
dry and 100 odd + degrees in the wet that
Castrol SRF offers, then there is either something wrong
with your Brakes or your Driving.
Regards,
The Gorilla.
Leave a comment:
-
Pete Collen at AP told me and they have itvon their website as posted above. It says do not use Silcon based with A. Are you waitimg for a memo from the queen or something??
POriginally posted by 3wheels3 View PostHow do you know this? I've heard others say it does but when asked they just say they heard it. I would like a definitive answer as am planning on using it.
Performance Friction clearly disagree with the statement.
...to maintain excellent vapour lock and corrosion protection, we strongly recommend that Castrol SRF be drained and refilled every eighteen months...
Race Proven: Widely used in racing, from Formula One World sports cars to Group A and 500cc Grand Prix motorcycles;
High Boiling Point: The exceptionally high dry boiling point (higher than 300°C) makes Castrol SRF ideal for use under arduous braking conditions such as rallying or racing. Castrol SRF exceeds the boiling point requirements of DOT 5 brake fluids;
High Vapour Lock Point: Castrol SRF has a very high vapour lock point (the more important measure of high temperatures performance under actual braking conditions) and has the additional advantage of sustaining high vapour lock point characteristics during its service life;
Compressibility: The compressibility of Castrol SRF is very similar to that of current DOT 3 and DOT 4 fluids. It can therefore be filled into any braking system used in motorsport with the exception of those for which a mineral oil is prescribed;
Miscibility: Castrol SRF is miscible with all conventional fluids meeting the US Federal Standards FMVSS 116 DOT 3 and DOT 4, ISO 4925 and current SAE J1703. The miscibility of Castrol SRF with conventional brake fluids means changing the brake system to Castrol SRF is easy. Drain and flush out the conventional brake fluid with Castrol SRF then top up the system with Castrol SRF. Although Castrol SRF is miscible with conventional brake fluids, topping up Castrol SRF with conventional brake fluids will reduce the benefits of the product;
Compatibility: Castrol SRF is compatible with seal rubber and metal materials used in braking systems using conventional polyglycol brake fluids;
Bleeding: Castrol SRF is easy to bleed like conventional brake fluids.
Leave a comment:
-
How do you know this? I've heard others say it does but when asked they just say they heard it. I would like a definitive answer as am planning on using it.Originally posted by shimmy View Postyep but your AP calliper seals dont:whistle:
Performance Friction clearly disagree with the statement.
...to maintain excellent vapour lock and corrosion protection, we strongly recommend that Castrol SRF be drained and refilled every eighteen months...
Race Proven: Widely used in racing, from Formula One World sports cars to Group A and 500cc Grand Prix motorcycles;
High Boiling Point: The exceptionally high dry boiling point (higher than 300°C) makes Castrol SRF ideal for use under arduous braking conditions such as rallying or racing. Castrol SRF exceeds the boiling point requirements of DOT 5 brake fluids;
High Vapour Lock Point: Castrol SRF has a very high vapour lock point (the more important measure of high temperatures performance under actual braking conditions) and has the additional advantage of sustaining high vapour lock point characteristics during its service life;
Compressibility: The compressibility of Castrol SRF is very similar to that of current DOT 3 and DOT 4 fluids. It can therefore be filled into any braking system used in motorsport with the exception of those for which a mineral oil is prescribed;
Miscibility: Castrol SRF is miscible with all conventional fluids meeting the US Federal Standards FMVSS 116 DOT 3 and DOT 4, ISO 4925 and current SAE J1703. The miscibility of Castrol SRF with conventional brake fluids means changing the brake system to Castrol SRF is easy. Drain and flush out the conventional brake fluid with Castrol SRF then top up the system with Castrol SRF. Although Castrol SRF is miscible with conventional brake fluids, topping up Castrol SRF with conventional brake fluids will reduce the benefits of the product;
Compatibility: Castrol SRF is compatible with seal rubber and metal materials used in braking systems using conventional polyglycol brake fluids;
Bleeding: Castrol SRF is easy to bleed like conventional brake fluids.
Leave a comment:
-
Hi,
I expect if you did a Brake test between Std CSL Brakes
and a 355mm BBK Kit then then the stopping distance
between the two would be very similar.
If you then continually repeated the Brake test, over a
period the BBK would still repeat its stopping distances
more or less, whereas the Std Brakes would start to fade somewhat.
Meaning if you are a 'Light' user of the Brakes, which
usually equates to a fast driver then for light Track use,
good Pads, S/S Hoses and some ATF Blue will be
fine.
If on the other hand you ride the Brakes hard, then the
Std Brakes, even with upgrades will be showing signs
of fade in two or three laps of any Track with spirited driving.
On the question of Brake Fluid, for Track Days, ATE Blue
is as good as it gets for the money.
Reason being, that if you require the extra 60 + degrees
dry and 100 odd + degrees in the wet that
Castrol SRF offers, then there is either something wrong
with your Brakes or your Driving.
Regards,
The Gorilla.
Leave a comment:
-
Cheers Jonathan, im aware that heat is the big killer, but given that some say that OEM 's are fine, and that by going the AP/PF route your are even ...finer !!:hahaha:..thats how Beckham would have put it !Originally posted by M5 Powered View PostYes, it is all basically to do with heat. The bigger the disc, the more heat it can handle and dissipate when your constantly slamming on the anchors (unless you go the ceramic route).
Also it means the further you can go on the track / race without the feel changing.
From reading round, Thorney supply Alcons (badged CSL CUP) as the preference for racing use mainly because of the sustained sessions and mono-bloc calliper design which is stiffer. But for normal CSL trackday use, AP's are more than good enough and you can use the OEM BMW rear disc.
Best
Jonathan
And all things being equal heat wise, the only advantage that a bigger brake setup has is shorter stopping distance surely? What im saying is that eventually if say a bunch of cars are all running various forms of BBK without heat problems, or any other brake related problems, then is the only advantage of say the biggest of the big... later braking? If so, my take on it is that if my bollocks, or anyone elses for that matter ! are bigger than the next guys rotors ... it soon becomes a moot point... doesnt it ??:smt102
Leave a comment:
-
Originally posted by shimmy View Postfeck me , Fuchs would have a heart attack :thumbs:
ere Shimmy, this looks like it could develop into to one of those Fuchs BBK threads !
lol
Leave a comment:
-
As has been said the larger rotor's will help with the dissipation of heat plus you get the added benefit of a little more stopping power:thumbs:Originally posted by DuncanR View PostAs a mere novice at this, would it be fair to say that the ONLY point of having bigger/better brakes is so that you can get on them much later in the corner, thus making your laptime quicker ? And if you are racing outbrake another competitor ... assuming that you do indeed get round the corner !!
Would it also be fair to say that if the above rings true, it requires much more skill and judgement in doing the above as timing is more critical, the braking zone is possibly smaller, and the margin for error much less?
If both of the above have any truth about them, would it be fair to say that at 52 years old, 53 in April, my PF's and AP's are more than adequate for what my brain could cope with? :hahaha:
As a mere whippersnapper to your 52 Dunc I am 26 but I bet I can't hustle a car around any quicker than you can! :bigcry: :hahaha:
Good thread this, nice to see what's available and what actually works and what doesn't
Leave a comment:

Leave a comment: