I'd consider 60k for a GT if for some reason beyond my control I no longer had my car, but at that price I wouldn't pay the premium to move from my lowly 332is msport lol edition to that.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Would you buy a Euro E36 M3 as an enthusiast?
Collapse
X
-
Yup-- you cannot import a 3.2 Euro M3 to California legally since it lacks OBD2. I don't think you could retrofit that to work since the DME would not communicate with the scan tools. I'm not sure you can federalize one either, come to think of it.Originally posted by Nate047In California, the Euro spec cars will never be able to pass smog legally without major modifications, the process of which would ruin "collector" status. Because of that, I would take the same lump of cash and build a S54 CA State BAR Certified swap and upgrade other aspects of the chassis to mimic or improve upon Euro spec performance. This is assuming you'd want to actually drive the car and not just look at it.
Or, get a P.O box in Arizona...
As much as I love my BAR legal S54 swap....if I had to pay someone to build one I would buy an E46 instead. Finding a shop that knew how (and was willing) to smog one, legally, post-BAR was an enormous pain in the ass too. I've heard of a couple shops charging around $20k for an emissions-legal swap, so as far as I'm concerned it's DIY-or-buy-E46.
I'd love a Euro 3.2 someday but I agree with Westopher. Unless the price was close I'd probably just save a bit more and satisfy my porschelust instead. The E36 is a great car but there are other great cars out there in the mid 20-30k range that I want to own.
Comment
-
That means you would sell your E36 M3 and add some more to buy a Porsche? Or you would keep the E36 M3 and buy another Porsche?Originally posted by westopherThe euro e36 is probably already 25-35% more all things equal. Add the cost of importation to that. At that price, I'd likely be saving a bit more and buying a Porsche.
Thats not to say it hasn't been worth it, and won't be worth it again due to changes in the market, and currency fluctuations.
My original post is more about if you can only keep one E36 M3 in your possession, would you rather keep/buy a US or Euro version given the potential price tag difference?
Comment
-
Good point! But there are many companies out there that can handle importing and logistics part of this.Originally posted by twentysevenIf cars were identical, i'd just go for the US version. Assuming the intention is collectibility then performance comes secondary. You'll have a much easier time finding a nice US example because the Euro cars are more scarce. Plus the logistics of actually acquiring it (exchange rate, transportation, inspection, etc) will be more work. Arguably you're better off spending that money on a car you'll be able to enjoy more.
The only car i'd consider importing is a GT. But they are Porsche money now, so all things considered you weigh all options when it comes time to write a check...
Just wondering would companies like EAG be importing and selling an Euro E36 M3 a few years from now? Probably some crazy price tag I guess.
Comment
-
I'm saying, if I had no e36 m3, and had the option between a quality US spec the same as mine (lets say 20k) a euro spec (lets say 30k) I'd likely save up some more money and buy a driver quality 993 or 964 (lets say 45k)
That said, if in my searches a 60k m3gt in excellent condition came up, I'd probably take that over all of them.
Comment
-
Hard to tell. But people ask crazy prices, even though they are not selling at these prices, but people are not letting them go for less.Originally posted by Hasan ShaikhHow much are they worth in Europe?
It's the EAG type companies, we have a few known one here as well, these do sell at crazy prices. But aimed at collectors/investors.
Comment
-
Indeed and it's an M3. That badge is desirable.Originally posted by Hasan ShaikhThanks. I can understand why people would not let go of them at a low price.
Its a very engaging car.
Over here the E36 M3 was never popular untill a few years ago. It was all about the E30 (homologation special, totally different body) and E46 (totally different body).
The E36 was and is just, well just like any E36 with M Aero package on it.
I know a few stories, and it happened to me as well, where people told (and this was even a car mech) that my car was not an M3 and I should remove the badge.
But it's also a bit of a bubble car's are into now. Suddenly everyone thinks every car is some rare, limited model that should command a high price.
Comment
-
Agreed. The reason I got an E36 M3 was because for the money, it's extremely fun. I can't think of too many cars in the price range that I really like, maybe an S2000 or a car like my Z4M Roadster. The fact that the US motor is very easy to maintain and is super reliable also factored in to my decision.Originally posted by SammyzukoHaha....well I'm sure the Euro is nice, but I don't feel like I'm missing too much with my modded S52. There are other cars I'd rather have for the money you're hinting at.
This car at unobtainium prices, whether Euro or US, doesn't make too much sense to me personally. There are other cars that are higher on my list.
Comment
-
For someone who already has a S52 M3 in good shape, that's already "good" enough and have a lot of fun.Originally posted by SammyzukoHaha....well I'm sure the Euro is nice, but I don't feel like I'm missing too much with my modded S52. There are other cars I'd rather have for the money you're hinting at.
I happened to have both kind of M3 (S52 and S50) in Taiwan where I come from. I still have both cars but no longer drive the S52 but only the S50 nowadays. My dad drives the S52 more than I do.
The US M3 with S52 is still a very nice car and is actually much more comfortable as a dd. But the S50 is way much more fun with more torque, horsepower and 6 speed. There are also a number of other stock goodies that are only available on the Euro E36 M3 such as the aluminum doors, headlight aim control with Bosch projector headlight, 7600 rpm red line, 280KM dial, oil cooler....etc.
In places like Taiwan where both US and Euro M3s are available, the price of US M3 is actually getting way less, especially for Pre-95 US M3. Many of the US M3 owners actually sold their cars and moved to Euro M3. Some even pay premium to import them from Japan.
I get you all enjoy the S52 M3, but I guess you would probably change your mind if you have the chance to sit in a Euro E36 M3. Not to start another thread about which is better, not the point here. Just talking about the collectibility and potential value in a few years time when both are available in the US market.
Comment
-
^I hear ya. I think all things equal, 99.9% of everyone would pick the Euro. I think that almost goes without saying. The real question is, at what point does the upfront premium not make any sense to do so?
For me personally, its at about $5k or so. Anything else over that, and I rather spend a few more and throw in an S54. Anything exuberant over that, which by the sounds of it is actually going to be the case, and I would rather get into a 997 or a handful of a lot of other cars. The E36 chassis is a great one, and I am glad a lot of people are realizing what some of us have been saying all along. But from a $$ perspective, there comes a point where the same money can get you something much better and just as enjoyable (if not more).
Comment

Comment