Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Would you buy a Euro E36 M3 as an enthusiast?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #46
    Has anyone checked the prices of the E36 M3s in Japan recently? Especially the low mileage S50B32 cars.

    Comment


      #47
      Originally posted by StJamesM
      does this (in your opinion) deter from the "collector" value , aspect?



      i've always wondered about that



      (this question is for everyone too)
      I mean, "yes" but to be fair, I don't agree with the collector's mentality that original is always better.



      There are some cheap ones that come up every now and then. This one's pretty sick, wide body and everything:



      https://suchen.mobile.de/fahrzeuge/d...GEAR&fnai=prev

      Comment


        #48
        OMG Yuck

        Comment


          #49
          Haha, what an abomination.

          Comment


            #50
            I'm moving to Germany in a few months and a S50B32 M3 is the first thing I'm going to buy.


            The market over there seems to be as inconsistent as it is over here, but overall they're more expensive. My budget for one with 100,000km or less is 20,000 EUR, or 23,683 USD.


            The plan is to bring whatever I buy back to the states eventually. I just need to sell my 95 E36 M3 so I have cash for a car when I get over there.


            Originally posted by warez
            As regulated by the NHTSA, 25 year old or older cars are legal for import into the US.


            Let's say a few years from now, some Euro E36 M3 (3.2 S50B32 in particular) are available in the US market as collector cars, as an enthusiast you are looking to collect an E36 M3. There are two choices in front of you:


            1) 1998 US E36 M3, Estoril Blue/Dove Gray, 5MT, S52B32, 240HP

            2) 1998 Euro E36 M3, Estoril Blue/Dove Gray, 6MT, S50B32, 321HP


            Assuming that Euro M3 is legally imported and can be registered. Both cars are in decent condition and under 100K miles.


            Question:


            1. Which E36 M3 would you buy?

            2. How much more are you willing to pay for the Euro E36 M3?


            Please feel free to share your thoughts and views on this!

            Comment


              #51
              Originally posted by M_Parallel
              And also it's biggest 'downfall'.


              Peak power is at 7400rpm, redline at 7600rpm. So to get the max out of it, you really need to rev it out.


              But absolutely, it just keeps going on going all the way to the limiter like a neverending story, which is a blast.


              It's kinda cool with SMG having the shiftlight and you just wait till it first starts flashing rapidly, then becomes solid, all in an eyeblink, flick the shifter (or paddle in my case), next gear bangs into place, repeat proces.


              Yeah it's cool.




              I've still seen people being on the fence about that. I've never seen a 100% proof of this. Some say it's the manual only, not the SMG.


              If anything, since the MSS50 is being reverse engineerd, it should be easy to see if there is some different 1st mapping and if so, should be able to be flashed out.


              Since I only use 1st to get the car going, it's not really something that would bother me.
              its pretty simple clutch out in first gear 1000 rpm go WOT until 7400rpm you can feel the shape of the torque curve via the acceleration its very linear. do it in 2nd and the difference is noticeable the midrange has a hump or kick from 2200rpm in 2nd and above gears. it is very evident they are hurting the midrange to help with traction with the stock MAP

              Comment


                #52
                BMW's own documentation states the S50b32 has more bottom end torque below 3500rpm, it might not be at all rpm below this but it certainly is not a torque advantage for the s54 at all rpm

                Comment


                  #53
                  Originally posted by digger
                  its pretty simple clutch out in first gear 1000 rpm go WOT until 7400rpm you can feel the shape of the torque curve via the acceleration its very linear. do it in 2nd and the difference is noticeable the midrange has a hump or kick from 2200rpm in 2nd and above gears. it is very evident they are hurting the midrange to help with traction with the stock MAP
                  LOL yeah, I understand. But I have SMG...



                  Otherwise I'm sure I would've noticed.

                  Comment


                    #54
                    Originally posted by Obioban
                    I'm certain having a cable throttle would make the low end torque of the s54 worse! Very likely the gains at low RPM over the S50B32 are due to not having to have the throttles open all the way
                    Eh, Euro is open to 90% from like 1700RPM and CSL to 95%. I'd bet there's some emissions reasons to keep the US models at 70%.

                    Comment


                      #55
                      Originally posted by Earthwormjlm
                      Not on the S54 with drive by wire, the throttles are RPM dependent, so flooring it does not mean the throttle butterflies are wide open.
                      Hmm that is interesting. And a little disturbing lol.



                      I guess easily rectified with a remap.

                      Comment


                        #56
                        There's something wonky going one with every one of those dynos at the low end-- NA M engine are known for wide flat torque curves. Every single one of those is bouncing around a ton at low RPM.


                        I could post dozens of dynos from dozens of S54s, and they'd look like the one I posted-- I none of them like the bouncy at low RPM those that evolve one.


                        Or, it's immediately noticeably if you drive a car with a torque dip like that-- drive a BRZ/FRZ/86 and it's hard to not think about the torque dip every single time you rev thought it.


                        If I drove an S65 with the torque bouncing around like that at low RPM, I'd probably stop driving it till I could diagnose the issue


                        So-- I don't think any of them are particularly accurate at low RPM.

                        2005 IR/IR M3 Coupe
                        2012 LMB/Black 128i
                        100 Series Land Cruiser

                        Comment


                          #57
                          E.g.


                          Normal S65 dyno (note no bouncing):

                          http://www.m3forum.net/m3forum/showthread.php?t=455882


                          normal S54 dyno (note no bouncing):

                          http://www.m3forum.net/m3forum/showthread.php?t=393964


                          Another S54 dyno (note no bouncing):

                          http://www.m3forum.net/m3forum/showthread.php?t=432240


                          Yet another (note no bouncing):

                          http://www.m3forum.net/m3forum/showthread.php?t=457232


                          A dyno of the same evolve tune as above, this time on evolves dyno, now with bouncing:

                          https://www.evolveautomotive.com/evo...mw-e46-m3.html


                          Sooo... I don't think evolve's dyno worked at low RPM properly :P

                          2005 IR/IR M3 Coupe
                          2012 LMB/Black 128i
                          100 Series Land Cruiser

                          Comment


                            #58
                            Originally posted by M_Parallel
                            Hmm that is interesting. And a little disturbing lol.


                            I guess easily rectified with a remap.
                            Why would you do that? It generates more torque. All of the drive by wire BMWs with independent throttle bodies do this.


                            Originally posted by digger
                            at 3250rpm on your graph 222/238=0.93%


                            0.93*355 = 331Nm which is less than 350 of s50


                            the euro s54 is 365nm peak heres a stock one


                            240/275 = 0.90

                            0.90*365 = 330Nm basically same as US spec


                            here compares all the various m3's s14, s50b32, s54b32, s65b40 etc you can see the e36 vs e46 turquoise vs green





                            evolve have heaps of other graphs for both e36 m3 & e46 m3 on same dyno. the e36 is stronger bottom end 2500-3500 give or take


                            e36
                            You're not at all suspicious of a dyno plot with that much wonkiness at low RPM? Looks they were dicking around at low RPM, before staying on the throttle full time, or their dyno measurements aren't accurate at low speeds.

                            Comment


                              #59
                              Originally posted by Earthwormjlm
                              Why would you do that? It generates more torque. All of the drive by wire BMWs with independent throttle bodies do this.

                              ...
                              Guess not than if it benefits the torque number.



                              Makes you think that my cable driven M3 should also benefit from not opening the throttle completely to gain more torque.

                              Comment


                                #60
                                It's all about that area under the curve

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X