Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

OE Euro headers vs copies - worth it?

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Obioban
    replied
    Originally posted by Epoustouflant View Post

    Slon sells 1:1 replicas of BMW parts with BMW logos, SKUs and original country of origin.
    At least in the case of the cabin air filter housing (don't know about the CSL trunk above, as I've never examined an OE CSL trunk for this), the BMW PN/logo is there because they made the mold using a factory part-- and the BMW info is molded into the plastic there, so it transfers.

    Slon isn't trying to pass stuff off as stock that isn't-- at every step of the way, they're marketed as aftermarket parts. To me, that is fine.

    If I were to pick an issue, it would actually be the word "Italy" there-- not the BMW info.

    Leave a comment:


  • Epoustouflant
    replied
    Originally posted by bigjae46 View Post

    This whole Russia thing? Thats the Russian government...not Slon. So I don't see the heartburn over buying from an individual citizen who's trying to put food on the table and make a living. Yes, I'm sure some of the money gets paid as taxes but is that a huge deal? And that's the beauty of being a 'Murican! Freedom! We can choose to boycott Russia....we can choose not to.
    Slon sells 1:1 replicas of BMW parts with BMW logos, SKUs and original country of origin. There's also a very well known individual on M3 forums that created a US incorporation to funnel money into Russia via Armenia, along with buying US supplies - all the while calling other individuals (including me!) for lacking morals and acting out of self interest.

    I told Obioban this wasn't my fight - so I'll leave it at that and I won't add anything to this post. You guys be the judge on the morals of it.

    Click image for larger version  Name:	WhatsApp Image 2021-03-15 at 8.23.34 PM.jpg Views:	3 Size:	397.4 KB ID:	241849
    Last edited by Epoustouflant; 11-13-2023, 06:13 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Maxhouse97
    replied
    Wow this thread went in a different direction

    Can anyone pass the part numbers of the LCI exhaust manifolds?

    Leave a comment:


  • Arith2
    replied
    Originally posted by 9kracing View Post
    China can copy tubing sizes, bends, and merges, and therefore can usually produce a header that does in fact make decent power... because they're just copying someone else's R&D.

    The part where they fall short is material quality, and welds. If your header's welds pop after a year, did you really save any money?

    China can't copy this.

    I don't think this is valid as I'm sure there are many Chinese individuals with welding talent. They are very capable. That's the header after 4 years and 25k miles. They're in great shape. Yes these a great bang for your buck. It took me an hour to get them off when I switched to SS V1s. Megan Headers also sound much better. I've really debated whether to sell my SS headers just for the sound.

    Click image for larger version  Name:	20231022_095803.jpg Views:	0 Size:	102.2 KB ID:	239079
    Last edited by Arith2; 10-22-2023, 07:16 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nate047
    replied
    Originally posted by usdmej View Post
    didn't they call out Titan 7 for essentially lying about having certifications, and had to retract all of it because the community/industry pretty much just loudly yelled, "wow that was unprofessional take it back!"?
    Not exactly, basically what happened was Apex called out Titan7/BimmerWorld (made in the same factories with the same methods) for not having TÜV or VIA/JWL certification or something along those lines. Thing is though, the wheels did meet the criteria for said certification, but since Titan and BW at the time we’re only selling in North America, they didn’t see the need to pay for the somewhat expensive testing and certification process(es) which makes sense. Apex leaned heavily on this technicality with their initial launch of the forged wheel lineup, which made them look petty. Also BW is one of the biggest retailers for Apex, so they really just said fuck you to a business partner for no reason. I dunno. Take it how you will but I prefer to not do business with companies who conduct themselves like that if I can avoid it, which I can.

    Leave a comment:


  • bigjae46
    replied
    Originally posted by Nate047 View Post
    Not that this is news or anything, but the fact that nearly everyone just turns a blind eye and gives Apex a pass is hilarious to me.
    Originally Apex just made boring looking wheels but in different specs - I love the 17x10s. Most bought them for track wheels since they were light and relatively cheap. But ever since they started down the forged path they have made wheels that are strikingly similar to other wheels. Although they are still light...they aren't throw aways like the original ARC8s. I guess they have to make more money.

    Leave a comment:


  • jet_dogg
    replied
    Originally posted by Nate047 View Post

    Yea, I even got after it with one of their guys in a Facebook group because he was trying to say they aren’t ripoffs of RI-A/FI-As, and there’s another new one that’s exactly like a ZE40. Not that this is news or anything, but the fact that nearly everyone just turns a blind eye and gives Apex a pass is hilarious to me.
    LOL!! Unconscionable that the guy is even trying to defend their position. He sounds like the ministry of truth for apex bamboozling people for their dollars in exchange for stolen intellectual property.​

    Leave a comment:


  • usdmej
    replied
    Originally posted by Nate047 View Post


    I don’t have a problem with Chinese/Taiwanese wheels if they aren’t flagrant reps, like Bimmerworld TA16 wheels or Titan7. I at least appreciate how those guys conduct themselves and are honest about what they’re doing and why..

    i'd say at most, apex just copies the styling of the big companies and only in a subjective manner. their engineering and the work they do providing enthusiasts with the fitment and sizing they actually want is all their own and extremely valuable imo.

    didn't they call out Titan 7 for essentially lying about having certifications, and had to retract all of it because the community/industry pretty much just loudly yelled, "wow that was unprofessional take it back!"?

    i run volks but would take Apex wheels over Titan7s any day of the week


    Leave a comment:


  • simonnim
    replied
    Originally posted by Nate047 View Post

    Yea, I even got after it with one of their guys in a Facebook group because he was trying to say they aren’t ripoffs of RI-A/FI-As, and there’s another new one that’s exactly like a ZE40. Not that this is news or anything, but the fact that nearly everyone just turns a blind eye and gives Apex a pass is hilarious to me.

    I don’t have a problem with Chinese/Taiwanese wheels if they aren’t flagrant reps, like Bimmerworld TA16 wheels or Titan7. I at least appreciate how those guys conduct themselves and are honest about what they’re doing and why. I own Volks, BBS, ACS wheels, and I also have BW track wheels and will undoubtedly buy more in the future. So I’m not anti China, I’m anti ripoff. It’s a hard line to tow sometimes lol.

    Another example of Chinese made products that are actually pretty good, and that I use professionally, are DJI drones and gimbals. They own a majority stake in Hassleblad too which is kinda wild if you know about cameras.
    it's easy to rip off and sell at a fraction of what a real one would sell for though. There's a market for it. Just filling the void, which is kind of smart play in economies of scale. And of course quality is decreased to meet said price point.

    Leave a comment:


  • bigjae46
    replied
    Originally posted by jet_dogg View Post
    I addressed your point perfectly with the second sentence.

    Additionally, if price wasn't a factor nobody in their right mind would pick megans over euros. End of discussion.
    But you totally missed the point and the word "Risk".

    Leave a comment:


  • Nate047
    replied
    Originally posted by jet_dogg View Post

    You see their newest blatant ripoff? Shameful, in fact embarrassing.
    Yea, I even got after it with one of their guys in a Facebook group because he was trying to say they aren’t ripoffs of RI-A/FI-As, and there’s another new one that’s exactly like a ZE40. Not that this is news or anything, but the fact that nearly everyone just turns a blind eye and gives Apex a pass is hilarious to me.

    I don’t have a problem with Chinese/Taiwanese wheels if they aren’t flagrant reps, like Bimmerworld TA16 wheels or Titan7. I at least appreciate how those guys conduct themselves and are honest about what they’re doing and why. I own Volks, BBS, ACS wheels, and I also have BW track wheels and will undoubtedly buy more in the future. So I’m not anti China, I’m anti ripoff. It’s a hard line to tow sometimes lol.

    Another example of Chinese made products that are actually pretty good, and that I use professionally, are DJI drones and gimbals. They own a majority stake in Hassleblad too which is kinda wild if you know about cameras.
    Last edited by Nate047; 10-20-2023, 06:31 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Jimbo's M
    replied
    Originally posted by maupineda View Post

    they days of “any China stuff is bad” are long gone.
    Says you and your limited scope. Personally, and certainly not just for quality's sake, I'll always look elsewhere first. Always.

    Leave a comment:


  • maupineda
    replied
    Many here have blinders on!

    i work for an OEM proudly American, and we more often than not have to use parts from our plant in China because guess what, their timelines are unbeatable and their quality is just as good, if not better.

    they days of “any China stuff is bad” are long gone.

    Leave a comment:


  • jet_dogg
    replied
    I addressed your point perfectly with the second sentence.

    Additionally, if price wasn't a factor nobody in their right mind would pick megans over euros. End of discussion.

    Leave a comment:


  • bigjae46
    replied
    Originally posted by jet_dogg View Post

    Of course it's black and white. You're risking the loss of money by betting it crosses the "just good enough" threshold or that it will suffice for your purposes and intents. If you don't want to gamble as I don't, you don't buy china period (among the whole host of other reasons). Nobody manufactures there other than for the fact that they can fulfill high volumes of cheap shit. The only example anyone can ever come up with is the iphone, that's it.

    Expensive isn't always good but cheap is always bad. If you've ever held a chinese made product in your hand and thought "this is nice" then you've just not owned anything nice of course. It is not made to any semblance of standard like it would be in taiwan, korea, japan, us, germany, italy, etc.

    Agree on everything else russia, the internet and holidays.
    I got the Megan headers for 1/4 the price that is normally charged for E46 headers. When I had those chinese made headers in my hand...I did in fact think to myself...these are nice!

    But you totally missed the point and the word "Risk".

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X