Bimmferworld vs Rogue Engineering engine mounts

[maupineda]

What didn't you like about the VT?

I have them but only have like 2K miles on them. I have some nasty vibration around 5K rpms on deccel though, I'm thinking it's them.

I had them and the car would be vibrate a lot to the point I would hear some rattles from the IP. Also, when shutting the engine it would screech a bit. I had to raise the RPM to 1k to overcome the vibration, they gave a very raw feel to the point it was unrefined in a "bad way". I went back and forth between BW and BMW Motorsport, then I learned about 034MS in a video from a fellow forum member here and chose to give it a go. They are much refined that VT, but at the same time the shift quality was not affected, and the vibrations went away. It sounds the BW, BMWM and 034MS are very similar. not sure the specs are shared.

BTW, I was able to bring back the idle speed without vibrations.

[4getr34]

looks like the consensus is to keep OE for street.

[4getr34]

Also OP - stay away from Rogue

elaborate?

[bmwfnatic]

Don't fuck with engine mounts unless your car is track only, thank me later.

[9kracing]

Also OP - stay away from Rogue

[9kracing]

I have used 034Motorsport. and loved them... much better than crappy Vibra-Technics the car came with.

What didn't you like about the VT?

I have them but only have like 2K miles on them. I have some nasty vibration around 5K rpms on decel though, I'm thinking it's them.

[maupineda]

I have used 034Motorsport. and loved them... much better than crappy Vibra-Technics the car came with.

[4getr34]

https://www.rogueengineering.com/Rogue-Engineering-E36E46E9X-Performance-Engine-Mounts_p_78.html

https://www.bimmerworld.com/Engine/Engine-Mounts/BimmerWorld-Performance-Track-Engine-Mount-Set.html

anyone know if these are the same? descriptions read very similar.