Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

What could cause my engine to seize?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Darbshaw
    replied
    Originally posted by sapote View Post
    If the welded clutch is true, then it can't happen on Day2 as the engine never crank on this day. But your wording sounds like you did hand crank it with plugs were out.
    Are you sure you did hand crank on day 2?

    On Day1: the engine fired up the first time then it shut down by itself or you did? In hind sight, if you had let the engine continue to run longer then now you don't have to cut the holes to deal with the welded clutch, as the running engine will not let the melt metal of clutch/guide tube to stop it, and eventually there is a gap between the twos.
    Day 2 is likely what caused the permanent weld. This was my mistake when typing it up.
    Day 2's crank with plugs out was under starter power. I ran the starter for a few seconds which probably welded and cooled. While this was cooling I went and put the plugs in and cranked under power to no success. I immediately suspected it was a power/ground issue.

    Day 1 shut itself off. I forgot to clear the DME of codes and reset it after the last engine. Maybe this caused a premature shutoff.

    Hindsight, maybe if I just ran the engine on the start of day 2 then it would have formed its own gap like you mentioned.


    The hole in the bell housing really annoys me but at this point I'll just have to deal with it. Bright side is I cut a clean square, should be an easy patch if I can get away with just this hole

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by Darbshaw View Post
    Day 2: Started with a plug out crank, same as day 1 everything seemed good. Went to put the engine under compression w/ plugs in and starter click. Nothing else to it. Stumped I decided to pull the starter thinking this may have gotten wedged in the flywheel and caused a jam, this was not the case. After I tried to hand crank the engine to find it completely seized.
    If the welded clutch is true, then it can't happen on Day2 as the engine never crank on this day. But your wording sounds like you did hand crank it with plugs were out.
    Are you sure you did hand crank on day 2?

    On Day1: the engine fired up the first time then it shut down by itself or you did? In hind sight, if you had let the engine continue to run longer then now you don't have to cut the holes to deal with the welded clutch, as the running engine will not let the melt metal of clutch/guide tube to stop it, and eventually there is a gap between the twos.

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by Darbshaw View Post
    So I have a single mass flywheel. I'm not entirely sure why it still has some wiggle to it. This is for sure friction welded on though.
    So your clutch has a few springs? I wonder if the friction disk and the center splined core are solid under nominal torque or there is some plays between them. This is the only way to have 1 -2mm plays on the crank if the clutch core is welded.

    Leave a comment:


  • Darbshaw
    replied
    So I have a single mass flywheel. I'm not entirely sure why it still has some wiggle to it. This is for sure friction welded on though.

    I appreciate the help and this is most definitely the culprit. I haven't been able to confirm for sure as I just got my hole cut. I kept the hole as little as possible. The plan is to weld this back up and hope it doesn't sacrifice too much strength.

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by Darbshaw View Post

    I agree that there shouldn't be and wiggle, but I think the welded clutch hits the nail on the head. Between school and work, I had no time yesterday for the VANOS but I'm hoping to attack the trans today. If the trans is a pain to remove, then I bet you this is my cause. I'm hoping that I can break it free without cutting into the bell housing. Any day to not use the welder is a good day.

    I guess the welded clutch was really common on E36's when using an E39 M5 clutch, if you didnt install backwards of OEM instructions. I don't believe I mentioned this earlier, but it's the dead giveaway. My car has an E39 M5 clutch plate with a ZF 5-Speed. So for all that matters in this case, an E36 with an E39 clutch.
    With the welded clutch, crank only can wiggle if and only if the FW is dual mass.
    Before diving in this hole, I would make sure I can hear the DM flywheel chattering when a helper rocking the crank, with tranny in neutral.

    " I have about 1-2mm of wiggle back and forth"
    If the crank pulley has 1 - 2mm wiggle, then it's not the case of a welded clutch, as the brand new DM flywheel has more rotation plays than this.

    Leave a comment:


  • jayjaya29
    replied
    Originally posted by sapote View Post
    Cut up the bell housing like this destroys it. I would rather do this: turn the crank with a long bar to break the weld off or the guide tube. I will take this bet.
    Tried this, got nowhere. I had an 18" breaker bar on the front crank bolt and used a jack to extert pressure on the breaker bar, it raised the car off the jackstands.

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by jayjaya29 View Post

    Yep clutch plate installed backwards. You're in for a world of hurt getting it out. You can get 2 of the PP bolts out through the slave cylinder hole. Then the others must be accessed through a access panel cut into the side of the bell housing. Heres the openings I made:

    Click image for larger version Name:	WhatsApp Image 2025-08-06 at 10.16.29 AM.jpg Views:	0 Size:	196.0 KB ID:	314625

    Once you have 4 of the 6 PP bolts out then you will need to rotate the transmission in relation to the engine to get the remaining 2 PP bolts out.

    Getting the clutch off from the guide tube is a whole other tub of fun involving 3 jaw pullers and sawzalls.
    Cut up the bell housing like this destroys it. I would rather do this: turn the crank with a long bar to break the weld off or the guide tube. I will take this bet.

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by jayjaya29 View Post

    I was able to rotate the crank a small amount via the front crank nut. I'm sticking with it being a clutch/flywheel issue.
    If the clutch was welded to the bolted down guide tube, then the crank still can be turned a few degrees due to the dual mass FW. For solid FW then zero degrees.
    I should correct my previous statement.

    Leave a comment:


  • jayjaya29
    replied
    Originally posted by Darbshaw View Post

    I agree that there shouldn't be and wiggle, but I think the welded clutch hits the nail on the head. Between school and work, I had no time yesterday for the VANOS but I'm hoping to attack the trans today. If the trans is a pain to remove, then I bet you this is my cause. I'm hoping that I can break it free without cutting into the bell housing. Any day to not use the welder is a good day.

    I guess the welded clutch was really common on E36's when using an E39 M5 clutch, if you didnt install backwards of OEM instructions. I don't believe I mentioned this earlier, but it's the dead giveaway. My car has an E39 M5 clutch plate with a ZF 5-Speed. So for all that matters in this case, an E36 with an E39 clutch.
    Yep clutch plate installed backwards. You're in for a world of hurt getting it out. You can get 2 of the PP bolts out through the slave cylinder hole. Then the others must be accessed through a access panel cut into the side of the bell housing. Heres the openings I made:

    Click image for larger version  Name:	WhatsApp Image 2025-08-06 at 10.16.29 AM.jpg Views:	0 Size:	196.0 KB ID:	314625

    Once you have 4 of the 6 PP bolts out then you will need to rotate the transmission in relation to the engine to get the remaining 2 PP bolts out.

    Getting the clutch off from the guide tube is a whole other tub of fun involving 3 jaw pullers and sawzalls.
    Last edited by jayjaya29; 08-06-2025, 07:22 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Darbshaw
    replied
    Originally posted by sapote View Post

    This can be easily verified: as the clutch welded lock solid to the bolted down guide tube, then the crank is also locked down solid by the clutch, and so there should be zero movement when trying to turn the crank both directions. Not this case.
    I agree that there shouldn't be and wiggle, but I think the welded clutch hits the nail on the head. Between school and work, I had no time yesterday for the VANOS but I'm hoping to attack the trans today. If the trans is a pain to remove, then I bet you this is my cause. I'm hoping that I can break it free without cutting into the bell housing. Any day to not use the welder is a good day.

    I guess the welded clutch was really common on E36's when using an E39 M5 clutch, if you didnt install backwards of OEM instructions. I don't believe I mentioned this earlier, but it's the dead giveaway. My car has an E39 M5 clutch plate with a ZF 5-Speed. So for all that matters in this case, an E36 with an E39 clutch.

    Leave a comment:


  • jayjaya29
    replied
    Originally posted by sapote View Post

    This can be easily verified: as the clutch welded lock solid to the bolted down guide tube, then the crank is also locked down solid by the clutch, and so there should be zero movement when trying to turn the crank both directions. Not this case.
    I was able to rotate the crank a small amount via the front crank nut. I'm sticking with it being a clutch/flywheel issue.

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by jayjaya29 View Post
    I think the issue is with the clutch assembly. I put a clutch on backwards on my e36 a couple years ago and the clutch fused itself to the fork guide tube on the first crank. Motor was locked up solid. I had to cut access holes in the bellhousing to unbolt the pressure plate from the flywheel.
    This can be easily verified: as the clutch welded lock solid to the bolted down guide tube, then the crank is also locked down solid by the clutch, and so there should be zero movement when trying to turn the crank both directions. Not this case.

    Leave a comment:


  • 332
    replied
    I agree, its in the bottom end/transmission.

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by Darbshaw View Post
    3. If there was piston to valve contact, wouldnt this be visible on a borescope? .
    It depends on where you look. I think it's very hard using the borescope to see piston hitting valve in this case as there is no indentation marks created on piston top yet.
    I wouldn't remove the vanos now, but I would verify the vanos timing first. But in order to check vanos timing, the crank has to go back to TDC.

    Don't loosen any vanos hubs bolts.

    1. Where are the crank and cams positions now? Post pics then maybe we can show how you get them back.

    But if vanos timing is wrong causing pistons hit the valves, then why you can't turn the crank CCW back more than just a few mm? A bad vanos timing should not cause the crank only can turn a few mm in both directions.






    Leave a comment:


  • jayjaya29
    replied
    I think the issue is with the clutch assembly. I put a clutch on backwards on my e36 a couple years ago and the clutch fused itself to the fork guide tube on the first crank. Motor was locked up solid. I had to cut access holes in the bellhousing to unbolt the pressure plate from the flywheel.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X