Best insurance policy for these cars?

[M Pete]

Same here. I've heard so many great things about Navy Fed as well. I've been with USAA for the better part of the past 15 years since I graduated college and went to ocs - they've been nothing short of amazing with all services I've used. I am insured with them on my Porsche (also financed), but knock on wood I've never filed a claim so what do I really know. The true mettle of an insurance co is how they treat you post accident and I haven't experienced that.

My M3 which was purchased brand new and has 30K over the past 17 years put into it, is insured with Hagerty.

I've used USAA for 27 years and have never had a problem, matter of fact I've been very surprised at how well they have responded. They paid out very well on a totaled M Roadster (my fault), replaced an entire transmission because I got caught in high water during a flash rain in Tampa, and several other accidents animal and parking lot related. Always treated me well. I compared between Hagerty and USAA for the M3 and Pcar since they are not daily drivers. If you put them in storage insurance during the winter they are the same price as Hagerty I found out.

[Steve]

I am thinking to try Grundy for my non-dd cars. Any reason that I shouldn’t?

[adamstuchlik]

Mine is with Grundy which was much more price competitive than Hagerty.

[big greasy taco]

I use a broker, who shops around all my cars, homeowners, etc.. using comparable criteria / coverage, and sets me up with the best combo... Prior to, I had USAA (very expensive) & State Farm (kept raising rates for no reason, they seemed sleazy). Most others wont insure the types of cars that I have come in and out