Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

School me on BMW/Porsche brake upgrade options.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    I don't know what to say now - so I'll just watch

    Comment


      I don't know what to say now - so I'll just watch



      :drums:

      Comment


        I'm sure it's not. But it's not all about weight either. The advantage of having a 30% bigger contact patch to use for braking is going to outweigh the loss of the extra pound or 2 from the csl calipers. I'm just not worried about gaining a pound or two; its not going to make a huge difference to me.


        Well it depends. I know you understand what's going on so I'll just say if I were going to upgrade I would want to get both better braking and heat dissipation as well removing unsprung mass at a key area (don't listen to the over simplification that removing unsprung mass is 1.5 times as much dead weight, in some places it is much more). It doesn't seem as noticeable but it will be there all the time, including power out, through the turns ect. Now if it's a street car I guess it wouldn't matter as much, although technically the car would be faster, the only advantage of your intended setup could be more stopping power for sudden, heavy breaking, but I'm not sure how often that will come in handy (hopefully not that much). Regardless it should be a pretty nice setup. Let me know how it goes.

        Comment


          I will comment when I get home, I'm at work right now...

          Comment


            I thought about an E46 upgrade...if nothing else for the cool rotors...Let us know how it works out...you are going to have a time finding quality rear rotors to match the x-drilled front floaters. Zimmerman and others make a x-drilled rear but they don't look like the factory ones.

            Comment


              WRX, you an engineer? I am.



              I also have the UUC-Wilwood 4 wheel, 6 piston front, brakes on my car. Your reference to only using 70% of the rotor, while technically correct, doesn't account for the effective brake torque generated by the pad contact area, (swept braking area) at a distance further from the center of rotation.



              What good do any brakes do that always cause the ABS to activate to prevent wheel lock at the slightest use?



              What good is a brake system that would ruin the brake bias? Do you really want the front brakes to do 95% of the work?



              Just because it doesn't look right to you, doesn't mean it isn't. Remember they thought the world was flat too... I'm sure they tried to burn people that thought otherwise...

              Comment


                I also have the UUC-Wilwood 4 wheel, 6 piston front, brakes on my car. Your reference to only using 70% of the rotor, while technically correct, doesn't account for the effective brake torque generated by the pad contact area, (swept braking area) at a distance further from the center of rotation.



                What good do any brakes do that always cause the ABS to activate to prevent wheel lock at the slightest use?



                What good is a brake system that would ruin the brake bias? Do you really want the front brakes to do 95% of the work?



                Just because it doesn't look right to you, doesn't mean it isn't. Remember they thought the world was flat too... I'm sure they tried to burn people that thought otherwise...



                I cannot agree more. Obvoiusly, I have the Wilwood setup and have experienced the improvement first hand. It is SUBSTANTIALLY better than the stock set up. I have to admit, I was a little concerned at first too, but I concluded that the concern was purely asthetic since the braking power was so much better! Just do it!



                Pete

                Comment


                  WRX, you an engineer? I am.



                  I also have the UUC-Wilwood 4 wheel, 6 piston front, brakes on my car. Your reference to only using 70% of the rotor, while technically correct, doesn't account for the effective brake torque generated by the pad contact area, (swept braking area) at a distance further from the center of rotation.



                  What good do any brakes do that always cause the ABS to activate to prevent wheel lock at the slightest use?



                  What good is a brake system that would ruin the brake bias? Do you really want the front brakes to do 95% of the work?



                  Just because it doesn't look right to you, doesn't mean it isn't. Remember they thought the world was flat too... I'm sure they tried to burn people that thought otherwise...





                  I cannot agree more. Obvoiusly, I have the Wilwood setup and have experienced the improvement first hand. It is SUBSTANTIALLY better than the stock set up. I have to admit, I was a little concerned at first too, but I concluded that the concern was purely asthetic since the braking power was so much better! Just do it!Pete



                  beat me to it guys.... :thumbsup2:

                  Comment


                    no offense but it just seems like you want to put "cool" stuff on your car. And while that's fine, i wouldn't really assert that its "better" than the alternatives.


                    like would it be cool and nice to have a 6sp and E46 ZHP brakes? yeah sure, would i put them on my car? yeah i guess if i got them REALLY cheap but are they necessary.....nah. Too many other things to get first.

                    Comment


                      WRX, you an engineer? I am.



                      I also have the UUC-Wilwood 4 wheel, 6 piston front, brakes on my car. Your reference to only using 70% of the rotor, while technically correct, doesn't account for the effective brake torque generated by the pad contact area, (swept braking area) at a distance further from the center of rotation.



                      What good do any brakes do that always cause the ABS to activate to prevent wheel lock at the slightest use?



                      What good is a brake system that would ruin the brake bias? Do you really want the front brakes to do 95% of the work?



                      Just because it doesn't look right to you, doesn't mean it isn't. Remember they thought the world was flat too... I'm sure they tried to burn people that thought otherwise...



                      That would mean that a caliper/brake setup in which 100% of the rotor is swept generates the exact same brake torque as a combination in which only 70% of the rotor is swept.



                      That doesn't sound the slightest bit of right. Reputable car manufacturers like BMW, AUDI, Mercedes, etc. wouldn't be spending millions on having matched calipers manufactured to their rotor sets.

                      Comment


                        That would mean that a caliper/brake setup in which 100% of the rotor is swept generates the exact same brake torque as a combination in which only 70% of the rotor is swept.



                        That doesn't sound the slightest bit of right. Reputable car manufacturers like BMW, AUDI, Mercedes, etc. wouldn't be spending millions on having matched calipers manufactured to their rotor sets.



                        6 piston bbk >>>> single pistion ZHP setup in terms of brake torque. i don't see how thats hard to understand. You spread the torque over a greater area of the disc and you must realize that 6 pistons are capable of a lot more force than a single one.

                        Comment


                          you do realize you have increased brake torque with 4 pistons in the wilwood kit, to increase brake torque applied to the brake pads right?

                          Comment


                            6 piston bbk >>>> single pistion ZHP setup in terms of brake torque. i don't see how thats hard to understand. You spread the torque over a greater area of the disc and you must realize that 6 pistons are capable of a lot more force than a single one.



                            you do realize you have increased brake torque with 4 pistons in the wilwood kit, to increase brake torque applied to the brake pads right?



                            This.



                            Although 6 piston calipers do have their drawbacks, which is why I will be going with a 4 piston variant when the time comes.

                            Comment


                              This.


                              Although 6 piston calipers do have their drawbacks, which is why I will be going with a 4 piston variant when the time comes.


                              If you have 1 large piston that presses on the pad applying pressure over a 70mm diameter area and 2 pistons @ 35mm diameter area you still have the same effective force being applied to the pads only in different spots, no?


                              Obviously multi piston calipers are superior to single piston calipers because of the different clamping characteristics. Pistons are being individually pulled from the rotor instead of the pads being pulled in a 1 piston design.

                              Comment


                                If you have 1 large piston that presses on the pad applying pressure over a 70mm diameter area and 2 pistons @ 35mm diameter area you still have the same effective force being applied to the pads only in different spots, no?


                                why would ANYONE bother with a BBK with multiple pistons if this was the case.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X