Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Weird tapping noise, pretty sure its not VANOS

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Nexite
    replied
    I couldn't figure the problem out, ended up trailering to a close friend's shop. The noise disappeared after trailering, it was run for almost an hour. I feel like it'll be back but not much I can do about it for now.

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by Nexite View Post
    I can't see anything touching the chain but if there is it's probably just lower down in the timing cover
    You can't see the lower chain guide condition until the cam sprockets are removed and then look down.

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by BL92 View Post
    Check the valve shims are seated
    Seated or not it can't cause the continuous noise while turning the crank 360.

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by BL92 View Post

    splined shaft bearing axial play

    worn diaphragm springs

    Your sprocket sleeve bolts are loose or snapped (07-12-9-905-536)​

    Exhaust Hub tabs broken
    Sorry but none of these parts can cause the noise when OP rotated the engine slowly in one direction.

    Leave a comment:


  • BL92
    replied
    Check the valve shims are seated

    Leave a comment:


  • maupineda
    replied
    Check tha the rocker arm retainers are not contacting anything, also inspect valve springs for any that may have cracked. I don’t thinkE VANOS would make any noise by torning the angine by hand. I would also check that the old chain guide did not break and a piece was left down there. If the noise coming from the top of may it be low down? Could also be any of the other chain guides

    Leave a comment:


  • eacmen
    replied
    Originally posted by Nexite View Post

    The video of the motor being turned over by hand is my car, I can't see anything touching the chain but if there is it's probably just lower down in the timing cover

    Edit: Wait is VC vanos cover?
    Valve Cover

    Leave a comment:


  • BL92
    replied
    Originally posted by Nexite View Post
    .
    Do you think it is something VANOS related? To me it sounds like something in the timing cover is rubbing on the chain. I am not too familiar with all the different parts of the VANOS system.
    Check

    splined shaft bearing axial play

    worn diaphragm springs

    Your sprocket sleeve bolts are loose or snapped (07-12-9-905-536)​

    Exhaust Hub tabs broken

    Leave a comment:


  • Nexite
    replied
    Originally posted by sapote View Post

    From the noise when manual rotating the engine, I think you need to open the VC and look, something catching the chain in the chain cover.

    BTW, 13 hrs to replace a bunch of vanos parts is too much, for $100/hr


    The video of the motor being turned over by hand is my car, I can't see anything touching the chain but if there is it's probably just lower down in the timing cover

    Edit: Wait is VC vanos cover?
    Last edited by Nexite; 12-20-2025, 03:41 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nexite
    replied
    Originally posted by BL92 View Post
    No new Exhaust Sprocket Hub either ? Broken Tab ?

    Oil pump disk could still be reused with new holes or not ? So core charge should of been refunded ?

    Could of just swapped it out for an enitre new core that beisan offers, would of saved labour and you would of gotten a new soleniod pack

    Wouldn't be running old oil through a new Vanos either
    Oil was changed when the VANOS was done, rod bearings were done at the same time. I've attached the whole invoice. This was done by the previous owner thankfully so I didn't pay these rates haha. I also did engine oil less than 4k miles ago and was going to do it right after the valve shims.

    Do you think it is something VANOS related? To me it sounds like something in the timing cover is rubbing on the chain. I am not too familiar with all the different parts of the VANOS system.
    Attached Files

    Leave a comment:


  • BL92
    replied
    No new Exhaust Sprocket Hub either ? Broken Tab ?

    Oil pump disk could still be reused with new holes or not ? So core charge should of been refunded ?

    Could of just swapped it out for an enitre new core that beisan offers, would of saved labour and you would of gotten a new soleniod pack

    Wouldn't be running old oil through a new Vanos either
    Last edited by BL92; 12-20-2025, 02:51 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • sapote
    replied
    Originally posted by Nexite View Post
    I still hear a noise while turning the motor over.
    From the noise when manual rotating the engine, I think you need to open the VC and look, something catching the chain in the chain cover.

    BTW, 13 hrs to replace a bunch of vanos parts is too much, for $100/hr



    Leave a comment:


  • BL92
    replied
    How long has the engine oil been in there ?

    splined shaft bearing axial play / worn diaphragm springs or worse,

    Your sprocket sleeve bolts are loose or snapped (07-12-9-905-536)

    Your shop should honour that as a warranty job, i would take it back

    Last edited by BL92; 12-20-2025, 12:42 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nexite
    started a topic Weird tapping noise, pretty sure its not VANOS

    Weird tapping noise, pretty sure its not VANOS

    Hi everyone! My car developed this weird tapping noise from the timng chain area on the intake side recently. I originally thought it was the valve shims but after completing them I still hear a noise while turning the motor over. The VANOS on the car was done ~10k miles ago and the upper chain tensioner was done ~1k ago. It sounded very similar to this car when it was running but I don't have a video of my car: https://youtu.be/mY-toVFeEFQ. If anyone's experienced anything similar, please let me know!!


    Turning the motor over:


    Click image for larger version

Name:	image.png
Views:	218
Size:	161.6 KB
ID:	330597​
    Last edited by Nexite; 12-19-2025, 08:09 PM.
Working...
X