Originally posted by sapote
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Grinding noise just off idle (video inside)
Collapse
X
-
I listen to the video again. Can you keep that grinding nose continuously by holding the rpm at certain value? In the video then rpm continued going up then down, and repeated and I think maybe you could keep the noise there by holding the rpm at that point. Or increase the rpm slowly to see if the noise behaves differently.
The rough noise sounds almost like the chain rubbing again the valve cover or something like that. It is not like hub driving tabs hitting pump disk holes, nor vanos rattling (bad roller bearing). I think it is related to the chain moving and rubbing something the wrong way.Last edited by sapote; 11-06-2026, 01:10 PM.
Comment
-
I can only make it do the noise as I transition from idle to just-off-idle. If I rev to 1200 and hold it - no noise. At idle - no noise. Any other RPM - no noise. Because of that it's noticeable when starting from a stop and gentle raising the throttle like in city traffic. While driving there is no noise (other than the normal clackety S54).Originally posted by sapote View PostI listen to the video again. Can you keep that grinding nose continuously by holding the rpm at certain value? In the video then rpm continued going up then down, and repeated and I think maybe you could keep the noise there by holding the rpm at that point. Or increase the rpm slowly to see if the noise behaves differently.
The rough noise sounds almost like the chain rubbing again the valve cover or something like that. It is not like hub driving tabs hitting pump disk hoses, nor vanos rattling (bad roller bearing). I think it is related to the chain moving and rubbing something the wrong way.
It's a tricky one for sure! I am also thinking chain related.
Comment
-
Following up in case anyone else has this issue.
I compared another E46 M3 to mine and it also makes this noise. Slightly less noticeable, but definitely there and can be both heard and felt.
I can only assume this is some internal noises caused by the radial piston pump or vanos drive hub. It is kind of annoying now that I can hear it, but I am guessing it was there for the past 50,000 miles and I just never noticed it.
- Likes 1
Comment
-
We are in the same boat, I had a shop the specializes in E46 M3s do my Rod Bearings, Vanos, Mounts, and Guibo - this was introduced as a by product. I have not written this up here yet, because I am still trying to sort it out. The shop when back in 3 additional time and was unable to correct it. I have done more research on on how the Vanos works than I care to admit, I have an AI Agent that I built as a master BMW tech that knows way too much about this engine. I have exchanged messaged with Corba, James and a few others who have noticed this issue - there is only one reported case of "fixing" it, and the user reported it was a sticking piston. Sadly, that was not the case on my car, but I have vibration analysis data showing what a "ticking" oil piston looks like and when its clear. For me, both cases produced this rattle.Originally posted by M3JXW View Posthello sorry to bring up an old post. I'm having the exact noise after vanos rebuild I see you compared to other cars presuming you just lived with it?
What I will tell you, with 100% confidence, is that on mine, like in the video, it is cause by the DME requesting a call for the exhaust solenoid. If you warm up your car, unplug the connector to the Vanos and blip the throttle, the noise will not occur. One mine, it's not guide, loose bolts, or anything else, if I sent you the list of what have been replaced on my car (by the shop) in an attempt to fix this you would not believe it. But the issue for me always go back to "rebuilt" vs "new" in all honesty.
There is something to the pressure in the system and fluctuations in that pressure when position calls are made by the DME, which is why I am gearing up to trend the pressure. I may use a transducer to record what is happening to pressure as the throttle is "blipped"
Over the winter break I am going to continue trying to work on this (I do not have time now), but I can confidently say, this one is happening on a lot more cars than people notice post rebuild. At some point I'll start a new thread a put everyting I have into it, I just need to run a couple more tests.
That said, this rattle in no way affects the driving, mine is strong as can be, and a blast to drive.
Comment
-
It was probably there before the rebuild. Check the video in post 21. While he does not blip the revs off idle over and over again, you can hear a low volume rattle as the engine is revved up off idle before and after rebuild.Originally posted by ~CSL~ View Post
We are in the same boat, I had a shop the specializes in E46 M3s do my Rod Bearings, Vanos, Mounts, and Guibo - this was introduced as a by product. I have not written this up here yet, because I am still trying to sort it out. The shop when back in 3 additional time and was unable to correct it. I have done more research on on how the Vanos works than I care to admit, I have an AI Agent that I built as a master BMW tech that knows way too much about this engine. I have exchanged messaged with Corba, James and a few others who have noticed this issue - there is only one reported case of "fixing" it, and the user reported it was a sticking piston. Sadly, that was not the case on my car, but I have vibration analysis data showing what a "ticking" oil piston looks like and when its clear. For me, both cases produced this rattle.
What I will tell you, with 100% confidence, is that on mine, like in the video, it is cause by the DME requesting a call for the exhaust solenoid. If you warm up your car, unplug the connector to the Vanos and blip the throttle, the noise will not occur. One mine, it's not guide, loose bolts, or anything else, if I sent you the list of what have been replaced on my car (by the shop) in an attempt to fix this you would not believe it. But the issue for me always go back to "rebuilt" vs "new" in all honesty.
There is something to the pressure in the system and fluctuations in that pressure when position calls are made by the DME, which is why I am gearing up to trend the pressure. I may use a transducer to record what is happening to pressure as the throttle is "blipped"
Over the winter break I am going to continue trying to work on this (I do not have time now), but I can confidently say, this one is happening on a lot more cars than people notice post rebuild. At some point I'll start a new thread a put everyting I have into it, I just need to run a couple more tests.
That said, this rattle in no way affects the driving, mine is strong as can be, and a blast to drive.
Comment
-
why not just video the needle moving on the vanos oil pressure gauge and see if in sync with the noise.Originally posted by ~CSL~ View Post
There is something to the pressure in the system and fluctuations in that pressure when position calls are made by the DME, which is why I am gearing up to trend the pressure. I may use a transducer to record what is happening to pressure as the throttle is "blipped"
Comment
-
Oh man, sorry about this. I did read the PM partially but was in a rush and ... forgot about it.Originally posted by ~CSL~ View Post
Already did, and it does. Check your PMs I messaged you about it 4 weeks ago I believe…
1. you cannot just replace with the anti-rattle kit parts and wash hands. The new parts need to be adjusted: filing lapping to fit with your old components.
2. cannot just assemble the new pump pistons into the new disk. make sure the pistons move smoothly in the bores, not loose not tight. If not the P will be lower than spec.
I don't see the video of pump pressure (in sync with the noise) PM. Can you post the video here via YT link?
Comment
-
I didn’t take one, but it does exactly what you would expect - i made a lot of discoveries between when I DM’d you and where I am today. Since then the vanos have been apart 3 more times…. Once I get into doing some more trouble shooting I’ll do I write up here. Right now my original disc in in, but I am not certain of the caps - and certainly they are not in their original bores. The car did not rattle like this before it went in for work.Originally posted by sapote View Post
Oh man, sorry about this. I did read the PM partially but was in a rush and ... forgot about it.
1. you cannot just replace with the anti-rattle kit parts and wash hands. The new parts need to be adjusted: filing lapping to fit with your old components.
2. cannot just assemble the new pump pistons into the new disk. make sure the pistons move smoothly in the bores, not loose not tight. If not the P will be lower than spec.
I don't see the video of pump pressure (in sync with the noise) PM. Can you post the video here via YT link?Last edited by ~CSL~; 11-06-2026, 08:21 PM.
Comment

Comment