Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Rogue Rasp Eliminator (v2) exhaust setups request

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Rogue Rasp Eliminator (v2) exhaust setups request

    I installed a Rogue Rasp eliminator v2. while it did do the job of removing the rasp altogether, it did introduce quite a bit of drone, obviously because of the fact i went catless.
    Did anyone else here go with the Rogue route? if so, what is your current setup. did you do anything to counteract the drone? my current setup is:

    - Euro Headers
    - Rogue v2 Section 1
    - Stock Section 2 (i have a supersprint resonated section 2 in storage that can be put back on)
    - SuperSprint Race Section 3

    combining the rogue with the supersprint race resulted in something pretty loud so i am looking to change that up.
    only videos i see are one of a youtuber (MunichVenom) that paired up his Rogue with an AP exhaust but later in his timeline it looks like he removed it. reaching out to him to see what happened there.

    for those that did read the thread, i had the clogged cats so i had to remove my euro section 1 and put this Rogue unit on. it's way too loud for street use so it's either change the exhaust to calm it down or source a catted section 1. any suggestions/insight appreciated.

    Thanks.
    '06 Carbon Black
    Sabelt, Brey Krause, MCS 2-way, SuperSprint, Karbonius, Epic, Volk

    #2
    to rephrase my question differently, in general has anyone gone catless and been able to control the sound or is going catless inevitably going to result in loud/droney.
    '06 Carbon Black
    Sabelt, Brey Krause, MCS 2-way, SuperSprint, Karbonius, Epic, Volk

    Comment


      #3
      I see your problem and I'm gonna tell you how to solve it.

      SS Race.

      Gotta go.
      2004 BMW ///M3 Carbon Black/Cinnamon 6MT
      2005 BMW ///M3
      Interlagos Blue/Black 6MT Dinan S3-R

      2008 BMW ///M3 Alpine White/Bamboo/6MT Track Build
      2000 BMW ///M5 Royal Red/Extended Caramel 6MT
      2004 BMW X5 Toledo Blue/Sand Beige 6MT
      2023 Toyota Supra //A91-MT CULG/Hazelnut 6MT


      Instagram

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by MarcoPolo View Post
        I installed a Rogue Rasp eliminator v2. while it did do the job of removing the rasp altogether, it did introduce quite a bit of drone, obviously because of the fact i went catless.
        Did anyone else here go with the Rogue route? if so, what is your current setup. did you do anything to counteract the drone? my current setup is:

        - Euro Headers
        - Rogue v2 Section 1
        - Stock Section 2 (i have a supersprint resonated section 2 in storage that can be put back on)
        - SuperSprint Race Section 3

        combining the rogue with the supersprint race resulted in something pretty loud so i am looking to change that up.
        only videos i see are one of a youtuber (MunichVenom) that paired up his Rogue with an AP exhaust but later in his timeline it looks like he removed it. reaching out to him to see what happened there.

        for those that did read the thread, i had the clogged cats so i had to remove my euro section 1 and put this Rogue unit on. it's way too loud for street use so it's either change the exhaust to calm it down or source a catted section 1. any suggestions/insight appreciated.

        Thanks.
        I have a SS section 1 with high flow cats that I will be putting up for sale soon if you’re interested. I was using it with euro headers, which will also be for sale. I have switched to SS oversized headers/ sect 1

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by MarcoPolo View Post
          to rephrase my question differently, in general has anyone gone catless and been able to control the sound or is going catless inevitably going to result in loud/droney.
          I have catless headers (Megan) but stock section 1/2/3 and the sound is very tame.

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by MarcoPolo View Post
            to rephrase my question differently, in general has anyone gone catless and been able to control the sound or is going catless inevitably going to result in loud/droney.
            Yep.

            Generally:
            Headers determine power.
            Section 1 determines smelliness (assuming headers)
            Section 2: determines bottom end/middle range power and rasp
            muffler determines drone.

            2005 IR/IR M3 Coupe
            2012 LMB/Black 128i
            2008 Black/Black M5 Sedan

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by Sharocks View Post
              I see your problem and I'm gonna tell you how to solve it.

              SS Race.

              Gotta go.
              i kinda expected that. thanks for the affirmation.

              Originally posted by Nick_P View Post

              I have a SS section 1 with high flow cats that I will be putting up for sale soon if you’re interested. I was using it with euro headers, which will also be for sale. I have switched to SS oversized headers/ sect 1
              hey nick what's up bud. i will hit you up. that's an option. you making me jealous with your new setup.

              Originally posted by DoubleSidedTape View Post

              I have catless headers (Megan) but stock section 1/2/3 and the sound is very tame.
              this helps. tells me you can run a catless setup and still have the exhaust controlled. thank you
              '06 Carbon Black
              Sabelt, Brey Krause, MCS 2-way, SuperSprint, Karbonius, Epic, Volk

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by Obioban View Post

                Yep.

                Generally:
                Headers determine power.
                Section 1 determines smelliness (assuming headers)
                Section 2: determines bottom end/middle range power and rasp
                muffler determines drone.
                met one of you friends this weekend. he was at Lightning with BMW CCA. he'll tell you.....my car was obnoxiously loud. saw some of the things you did. nice setup he has.
                '06 Carbon Black
                Sabelt, Brey Krause, MCS 2-way, SuperSprint, Karbonius, Epic, Volk

                Comment


                  #9
                  I chased this issue for so long till I decided to just go for the quietest aftermarket muffler I know of, the SS Street.
                  2003.5 E46 M3 Silver Grey/Cinnamon

                  MCS - Vorshlag - GC - Hotchkis - Supersprint - BBS - Brembo - Dinan - PSMax - SDW - VinceBar - DMG - Haimus - Karbonius - AEM

                  http://www.instagram.com/sid_e46/
                  Journal: https://nam3forum.com/forums/forum/m...grey-speed-run

                  Comment


                    #10
                    I'm on stock headers and section two with RE Rasp as section 1. When I had my stock muffler no drone, but when I moved to my RE Diablo the drone kicked in at 2 to 3k RPMs (roughly).
                    3.91 | CMP Subframe & RTAB Bushings | SMG (Relocated & Rebuilt) | ESS Gen 3 Supercharger | Redish | Beisan | GC Coilovers & ARCAs | Imola Interior | RE Rasp | RE Diablo | Storm Motorwerks Paddles | Will ZCPM3 Shift Knob | Apex ARC-8 19x9, 19x9.5 | Sony XAV-AX5000 | BAVSOUND | CSL & 255 SMG Upgrades | Tiag | Vert w/Hardtop

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by Sid_E46 View Post
                      I chased this issue for so long till I decided to just go for the quietest aftermarket muffler I know of, the SS Street.
                      how did that turn out? considering it's the quietest, i'm guess it still had some tone with the added sound it was being fed, no?
                      '06 Carbon Black
                      Sabelt, Brey Krause, MCS 2-way, SuperSprint, Karbonius, Epic, Volk

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by MarcoPolo View Post

                        how did that turn out? considering it's the quietest, i'm guess it still had some tone with the added sound it was being fed, no?
                        It sounds perfect IMO, almost stock sounding when I'm driving casually but does have some volume to it when I get on it,

                        I had an Eissenmann, Meisterschaft and Dinan muffler previously and they all droned. I do also have SSv1s which are regarded as the loudedst/raspiest headers you can buy.
                        2003.5 E46 M3 Silver Grey/Cinnamon

                        MCS - Vorshlag - GC - Hotchkis - Supersprint - BBS - Brembo - Dinan - PSMax - SDW - VinceBar - DMG - Haimus - Karbonius - AEM

                        http://www.instagram.com/sid_e46/
                        Journal: https://nam3forum.com/forums/forum/m...grey-speed-run

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Dixis Spirit section 3 doesn't drone if you can find one. Sounds like stock on the highway.
                          Instagram: @logicalconclusion

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by Sid_E46 View Post

                            It sounds perfect IMO, almost stock sounding when I'm driving casually but does have some volume to it when I get on it,

                            I had an Eissenmann, Meisterschaft and Dinan muffler previously and they all droned. I do also have SSv1s which are regarded as the loudedst/raspiest headers you can buy.
                            what section 1 do you have in this setup?

                            Originally posted by EthanolTurbo View Post
                            Dixis Spirit section 3 doesn't drone if you can find one. Sounds like stock on the highway.
                            buddy of mine has one for sale....that's $$ though.
                            '06 Carbon Black
                            Sabelt, Brey Krause, MCS 2-way, SuperSprint, Karbonius, Epic, Volk

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Originally posted by MarcoPolo View Post

                              what section 1 do you have in this setup?



                              buddy of mine has one for sale....that's $$ though.
                              I have the SS Section 1 that mates to the SSV1s with 2 Vibrant resonators welded in.
                              2003.5 E46 M3 Silver Grey/Cinnamon

                              MCS - Vorshlag - GC - Hotchkis - Supersprint - BBS - Brembo - Dinan - PSMax - SDW - VinceBar - DMG - Haimus - Karbonius - AEM

                              http://www.instagram.com/sid_e46/
                              Journal: https://nam3forum.com/forums/forum/m...grey-speed-run

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X